Firstly, thanks for the kind words. I’m reminded of what someone told me a long time ago on a French forum - what counts is not what you get out of it but what you put in. I do my best, but I think everyone else does too, including your good self, hence the fact that WB is such an interesting place to hang out and chew the cud.
I can quite believe that Burgundy is completely different to Bordeaux - the estates are so much smaller. It’s a region which for many reasons I just never got into, but what you describe is what I have experienced in the Loire.
In Bordeaux, it’s obviously hard to get personal experiences, even in the family-run châteaux, but it helps to write ahead of any visit. Obviously, a really personal visit with someone like the cellar master is excellent!
Most châteaux are at last beginning to cotton onto the possibilities of wine tourism (it has taken them long enough), but for every d’Issan, which really looks after visitors properly, there is a Dauzac which does not. There is still a lot of progress to be made. Practically all the châteaux are closed to visits on Sundays in July and August. How silly is that? Not only for tourists visiting the Médoc, but for Bordelais themselves - when are the latter supposed to come? Worse still, there are places like Brane which are not even open for any visits in the summer. All this accentuates the gulf between the haves and the have-nots in what is mostly a very poor area.
I think that in the future, more and more châteaux will do as Giscours are doing for example. We were unable to visit this year, because of works on the cuvier, but next year, we will certainly go. Their website is one of the best I have seen: Welcome to Giscours - Château Giscours Grand Cru Classé in 1885
They have clearly thought about how to make a visit something more than just the usual tour of the cellar (one steel vat is much the same as another), even if they still offer that possibility too. Unsurprisingly they are open on Sundays.
I’m glad you had better times at PB and LB than we did - we may have just been unlucky and we aim to go back at some point to see if they have changed.
You should definitely head back to the Médoc at one time - we only began visiting again in 2019, after a 15 year break, and I must say that it’s a lot more interesting now than before. So if I have inspired you to do so, that’s great!
Mark, I can only commiserate. Since we started visiting châteaux again three years ago, we have now visited Sociando, Gruaud, Beychevelle, HBL, Lagrange, Lafon-Rochet, D’Issan, Pichon-Comtesse, GPL, Clos du Jaugueyron, Prieuré-Lichine and Dauzac - the latter being the only disappointing one. 20 years ago, there were a lot more disappointments, so they are getting better, but clearly there is still work to be done.