Virtual Tasting for Charity Week 4 - Rosé - Dec 14-21 for Doctors without Borders

This is my first go at this, and my theme, rosés, is a little more prosaic than the two previous great weeks from @Chris_Seiber and @Jim_Stewart , but let’s see what we can come up with. (Being based in Hong Kong, I may be a bit slow in any responses here - I’m asleep when many of you are awake.)

It seems to me that rosés (at least still rosés) have long languished as a “last resort” option in many people’s minds, often suggested as a wine for non-wine-afficiandos. But that really does them a disservice. They come in a huge range of styles from a huge range of places, some looking like a white wine with just a faint salmon/copper tinge, some pretty much indistinguishable from a light red wine, and everything in between. Different countries/appellations allow different methods of production: by skin contact, saignée or blending, and some (particularly Italy) have other terms for it in some areas (cerasuolo, chiaretto, as well as rosato).

A lot of it is made to be drunk young, but some styles such as cerasuolo and champagnes can take (and benefit from) some aging.

Many people see rosé simply as a light, summer “on the porch” type thirst-quencher, and whilst many of them are pretty good at that job, there are others that are great food wines or wines to contemplate. And hence my choice of rosés as the theme in what many would regard as their “off season” - let’s look at them as wines for all seasons and see which ones others are drinking.

So you can empty my wallet as usual by US$5 for each tasting note posted here for any sort of rosé wine (still, sparkling, even the currently fashionable “natural” sludges), US$10 if accompanied by a picture of you with a bottle, and since four countries (France, Spain, USA, Italy) make 75% of the world’s rosés, in a bid to expand our horizons, an extra US$2 in either case if the wine isn’t from one of those four countries.

And so to my chosen charity. I thought about picking one of the small local ones here in Hong Kong, but maybe that wouldn’t resonate so well with the audience here on WineBerserkers. So I’m going with Médecins Sans Frontières (or “Doctors Without Borders” as it is known in the USA).

I guess this charity is already known to many of you (I’m aware that there are many medics on these forums) - their role is to provide medical assistance to people affected by conflict, epidemics, disasters, or exclusion from healthcare, whatever the local politics, religion or other fractious issues. They are quite a big operation now, but their funding is 97% from individuals, and over 80% of their expenditure is on direct operational work. Volunteers (medics and others) come from all over the world to work on the various projects for as much time as they can afford. You can read in a lot of detail about what they have achieved over the years, their funding, organisation and so on, on their excellent website.

So that’s the plan for this week - go find a rosé or two from your cellar (or get down the shops if you haven’t got any) and tell us what you think. I’ll get one of mine up here later today (I draw the line at drinking at 10am, even for a good cause!)

If you can add a good story around your experiences with rosés then so much the better - it is, after all, often associated with romantic (or attempted romantic) moments.

7 Likes

Great theme & charity Paul! How do you feel about including sparkling roses?

1 Like

Sorry - I’ve made the post more explicit - I’m absolutely fine with any type of rosé: still, sparkling, even the abominations known as “natural” wines (although quite what constitutes a rosé amongst the sludge may be open to debate).

OK, so here’s my starter. This evening Sabrina (that’s the missus) and I have been enjoying two rosés. First a rosé de saignée which, frankly, I enjoyed somewhat more than her, and then one of Lebanon’s finest products which we get through quite a lot of.

We’ve only been married for about 18 months, but been together a bit longer than that and exploring the world of wine is one of the things we greatly enjoy doing together. Rosés, both champagnes and still, have been a big part of that and long may it continue!

Anyway, here are the two tasting notes and a picture of me with the bottles some way through the evening…

  • NV André Jacquart Champagne Premier Cru Extra Brut Rosé de Saignée Experience - France, Champagne, Champagne Premier Cru (14/12/2022)
    This is really rather nice indeed...
    80% PN (Vertus), 20% C (Mesnil-sur-Oger)
    Tirage 6-2016
    Disgorgement 7-2019; dosage 4g/l

    The nose brings quite rich red fruits overlaid with minerality. The palate is really nicely balanced for my taste. Crisp acidity, red fruit that sits nicely between tart and rich, and a sort of granite minerality that persists with some light tannins into the quite lengthy and more-ish finish.

    Overall this is very much to my taste, going well as an aperitif and then pairing with some Vietnamese food. And very decent QPR at the ~US$46 that I paid. (92 points)

  • 2020 Chateau Musar Musar Jeune Rosé - Lebanon, Bekaa Valley (14/12/2022)
    We've had a few of these 2020s now and they have become essentially our default daily drinker. It works as an aperitif or with a wide range of foods.

    As always with anything Musar there's a little bottle variation, but always an interesting mix of red and orange citrus fruit on the nose and on the palate, with a nice amount of acidity and just a hint of tannin. The finish is nicely drying, with the a little of that crisp bitter orange acidity.

    For ~US$17 these is something that we will be getting through quite a few of over the coming months. (89 points)
2 Likes

@P_a_u_l_Christensen , Do you have any experience of the Musar Jeune with a few years (or more) of age?

I just looked it up, it’s a saignee rose of Cinsault (85%) and Mourvedre (15%).

Their grand vin rose is actually a white wine made of Obaideh and Merwah, then with 5% Cinsault added to give it color, so not a traditional rose in composition (or really in how it tastes and feels).

1 Like

NV Duval-Leroy Champagne Brut Rosé Prestige

From 375ml. First time having the NV rosé from Duval-Leroy, and, while pleasant, I have to say I was hoping for a little more. In the glass, the effervescence is on the relaxed side and the color is a light-to-medium salmon. On the nose, there’s some honeysuckle while on the palate peach and white cherry are the prominent notes. Not a lot of complexity but easy to drink. Probably not a re-purchase. I like a little more crispness in my bubbly. 88 pts.

Sorry, no picture this time around.

1 Like

Henri Goutorbe Brut Rosé

cépage 75% Pinot Noir, 25% Chardonnay
(12% vin rouge of Pinot Noir)
assemblage 75%, 25% reserve wine
village/vyd Aÿ Grand Cru; chalk
malo Yes
élevage Stainless Steel
sur latte 36 Months

Dosage: 9g/l

Farming Practice : Sustainable

Disgorged: 1/21, Base 2017?

Very pale pink. Lightly aromatic nose. A bit muted. Strawberries. Light sweetness such as Meringue. Mild, fine mousse. Medium tart. A bit sweet for my tastes, but not to the point of cloying.

I ordered this pre-arrival late last year untasted and when my Champagne tastes were in their infancy. Grand Cru at under $40 seemed like a great deal. And maybe it is for what it is. But stylistically, I’d rather drink something with a more character and cut. I suspect most people would find it very pleasing and quaffable.

1 Like

2021 Jolie Laide Vin Gris Sonoma County
Watermelon, peaches, wet stone minerality, tangy acidity. We put this one on auto-drain. Darn tasty.

Cheers!



1 Like
  • 2015 Domaine Comte Abbatucci Faustine Rosé Vieilles Vignes - France, Corsica, Ajaccio (12/14/2022)
    Not at all promising to start, with signs of seepage, with a cork was soaked through, and an initial waft of oxidized sherry notes on first pour. But all is well in the end. that A lovely copper-tinged rose that captures light beautifully. Complex on the nose, showing some white peach, saline minerals, lemon peel, and some nuttiness. Still shows trenchant acidity on the tongue, with a complex and fascinating array of peach, gummi-bear, iodine/seaweed brininess, and a bit of salami-esque umami. Fabulously rich texture for a rose. Perhaps showing just a tad tired on the finish, with some nutty tones, but still has a ton of life. (92 points)

Posted from CellarTracker


2 Likes

Looking back at my TNs it seems that I haven’t had any of the Jeune Rosé older than about 3 years from vintage, so I have no idea what happens after that. The producer website does say “First produced in 2007, these unoaked, vibrantly fruity wines, made from the fruit of youthful Bekaa Valley vines, were introduced to meet the demand for a ‘current drinking’ Musar range” so they don’t appear to be designed for aging.

If you drill down to the individual vintages the blend does vary a little - the 2020 is 80% cinsault, 20% mourvèdre according to the data sheet.

I must admit that the “grand vin” rosé is my least favourite of Musar’s wines - the couple of vintages I have tried felt rather disjointed to me.

1 Like

2018 Quivira Wine Creek Ranch Rose

Reached for this one to pair with an apple and goat cheese salad and it did the trick nicely. Good balance between light red fruits, a bit of honeycomb, and well rounded salinity and earthiness. Light enough on it’s feet to drink on it’s own or pair with foods as long as they aren’t too rich.

2 Likes

Drinking this while staring at the tree tonight.

I’ve been on this sparkling rose for about 5 years. Here is a note from last year hitting the high points. Won’t change the world but will feed the savages in a party, make sparkling cocktails, or just sip on something you don’t want to fight with.

If you’re

1 Like

Bang go my plans for romantic a moonlight rosé on the waterfront overlooking the great Hong Kong skyline…

Instead I have this, and 5 days of isolation:

So there’s nothing for it but to crack another of our daily drinker that is the 2020 Musar Jeune Rosé.

Ugh! Sorry to hear that. Best of luck getting better quickly.

2 Likes

A sentimental favorite.

A perfect rosè sunset at the BBQ.

2 Likes

Champagne Cheurlin Rose de Saignee - Saignee rose, first time with the producer, bottle off the shelf at the PA State Store. Very rich, strawberries and cream, reasonable body. A bit too sweet feeling to me, but would work very well for a crowd.

1 Like

This is a really interesting looking wine - we’re always on the lookout for slightly different rosés. Sadly at the moment I can’t find a supplier here in Hong Kong, but I’ll definitely be keeping my eyes open for it.

Nobody’s triggered the extra $2 for non-(Italy, France, USA, Spain) yet though (except me with our Musar).

Thanks for this - Corsica is somewhere I can’t recall having any wine from at all. But it’s still France so no extra $2!

I can get recent vintages (2020, 2021) of this here, so I’m tempted to give it a try.

Thanks. In fact I’m asymptomatic, so no worries. I just have to isolate with the missus for 5 days then we’re good to go (assuming a negative test).

Txakolina, pronounced “chalk-o-lee”, is a very popular variety in northwestern Spain. It’s a bit like Vinho Verde.

It’s what the local drink while eating pintxos. Fun stuff.

1 Like