Young People's Wine Thread - The Good, Bad, and Mediocre

While there are a variety of threads on affordable wine (see link below), young people drinking wine, etc., I have not found a thread that serves as a home for young people to freely discuss their wines. Given that I’ve now spent 100 hours on this site (within 150 days), it is time for action.

I’d love to have this thread become a home for people (whose age begins with a ‘2’) to come together to share their wine experiences. Personally, I feel that many of the bottles I open are simply not worthy of posting elsewhere. Despite that, there’s still a desire to discuss them. I love wine and want to consistently share that passion without feeling a need to go out and find a special bottle.

So, please, post the bottles you bought at random in the local wine shop. Post the bottle you had at your parent’s house. Post about the thought you had while imagining what bottle you want to try next. I plan to read and reply to them all.

https://www.wineberserkers.com/t/tasting-notes-for-wines-you-enjoyed-which-retail-at-us-20-or-less/329975/1

23 Likes

To begin, a long post about some recent wines that have fallen under the “how did I end up with this” category. I’m not sure if other twenty-somethings have these bottles, but my fridge is full of them. Bottles from a wine club my girlfriend was gifted. Bottles my parents have left at my apartment. Bottles that I must’ve bought at some point, but don’t recall whatsoever.

They fill the fridge (thus saving my budget) and serve their purpose when I’m wanting something that will work with dinner. Sometimes they’re even good! Often, though, they are like this bottle of

Danze della Contessa 2023 Solenta Chardonnay – A bottle of pure mediocrity. My mom had picked up some sort of Italian white, and the grocery store had this. I’m not sure if I’d had an Chardonnay from Tuscany, and was intrigued. Alas, there was nothing to be excited about. A bit of funk to begin (that I found pleasant) was the only positive factor. “Slightly tropical fruits that lack any sort of inspiration” is my note.

That was the bad.

Bastide Miraflores Vieles Vignes 2020 Syrah - Grenache – 22000 ratings on Vivino is all I needed to know about this wine. It was a Monday night, burgers were about to be grilled, a bit of peppery red wine was going to be perfect. I imagined the delectable notes that would fill my nose upon popping the cork, and remembered this bottle we’d received from the local restaurant’s wine club a few months back. So, out it came! I popped the cork and was immediately met with an extreme sense of blueberry. Sure, there was some pepper there, but the profile was almost entirely fruit. As I

thought about the effects of wine on my body, whether this bottle was even worth the alcohol, there was a moment of questioning. No good wine should ever make me question if it’s worth drinking (ok, maybe after the 5th glass).

That was the mediocre.

That means there is only room for the good left!

Kendall Jackson Vitner’s Reserve 2022 Cabernet Sauvignon – A wine my parents had received as a gift. We planned to pour it into a bourguignon, but a sip was taken out of intrigue. It was good! A complete surprise. I expected to be drinking vanilla extract with some red fruit on top, but this was earthy and rustic. Fruit level was low, though some tasty cassis is in my note. I really recall the amazement of having what I’d fully expected to be a cooking wine be good! And, despite my small experience, California cabernet from large producers is typically not my first choice. However, this really was a bottle I remember fondly. Will I buy it again? Probably not. But, it was a great surprise and a good bottle for that evening with family.

*As a disclaimer, I write this while finishing a bottle of Domaine Pierre Usseglio et Fils 2000 Cuvee de Mon Aieul – not a gift nor a grocery store wine from the family. A bottle that my buddy pointed to when I told him “pick anything out of the fridge, we will open it and see how it goes.” I’m fairly certain his preferred wine is Stella Rose blueberry wine, or anything else with 100 g/L of sugar, but I was true to my word. And it gave me a chance to use my Durand – I love that thing. So, it’s not all bad and mediocre wines. But those seem to be the majority. One of these days I’ll get around to spending enough on wine to make sure it’s always interesting at the very least, but that’s not going to be today or tomorrow.

Cheers!

11 Likes

Me, a 30-something: Hell yeah!

bart simpson is sitting at a podium giving a speech while homer simpson stands behind him|833.0000000000001x633.9646017699116

49 Likes

Paula Kornell Brut is fantastic at $18 + taxes. But finding $20 good domestic wine is hard af tho.

Since we’re at it, are we talking MSRP or close-out bottles? K&L has a great fire sale on Pinot and Syrah for sub-$30 and sub-$20

1 Like

I felt the same way!

2 Likes

Make the 30s thread. Not too old. Not too young. Just right. The Goldilocks thread.

11 Likes

No longer that young, but there should be more space on this forum dedicated to wine that is not expensive. There are tons of good wines out there that are pretty damn good without being life changing/epiphanies.

The other beauty of being early in your wine and life journey is that there is naturally more excitement since stuff is new. When I first got into wine in my 20s, I went to every tasting I could for a couple years. Got to try about 5000 wines in two years and found a ton to be excited about. A 2011 Morgon from a less celebrated producer was one of the first wines that got my attention

Fifteen years later and I’m jaded and think more about chasing the dragons than finding exciting things or just plain good ones…And then I drink one of Boonville Road’s 2018 Carignan from Mendocino and can’t figure out why I spend so much energy hunting down more “prestigious” wines.

So don’t let the vocal and frequent posters of $100-$3000 bottles make you think that you should be chasing those things. POST NOTES about other wines

7 Likes

Me, at 41 reading this thread:

“Hello fellow young people…”

22 Likes

How about begins with a 3 but ends with a 0 or are we sticklers

1 Like

Let’s up the ending digit to 5 and it should be good

That sounded great then I realized I onky have 8 months left. Where did the years go?

3 Likes

This was a dagger to the heart. I still think of myself as young. :rofl:

3 Likes

The torch is yours, young man, but for the record,
image

3 Likes

Wow! Lots of people are ready to discuss the definition of a young person. Perhaps I can adjust the framing of my initial requirements to appease those who fall into the “I’m not that old” category. Let’s call it the Young People’s Wine Thread still, but I honestly don’t care if you’re 20 or 80. I just want to talk about wine at a level myself and other newbies to this hobby can feel comfortable in. As @Dan_Sch said, let’s POST NOTES about wines that are uninteresting, mediocre, and occasionally fantastic!

1 Like

Good distinction! This thread is not about bottles with a low MSRP (although those are welcome). I recently ordered a mixed case of 12 for $250, and the MSRP of two particular bottles would’ve exceed that amount. Those are the exciting finds and the ones that cater to myself as a young person with more time than money.

1 Like

In a perfect world we really shouldn’t need a thread for this. More people Than you think are interested in hearing about wine that’s not all high end burgundy. In fact I typically skip that stuff at this point because how many times have we have already heard it.

I get it though it can be intimidating at first to take a flyer and post on a more normal range bottling. Then if you get little feedback it feeds into the narrative that no one must be interested, which isn’t necessarily true.

So all in all I don’t like the trend of compartmentalization of threads, but understand how it’s easier to just make a less visible Post within them.

I guess I’m thinking it would be nice to have some more variety in Wine Talk rather than the same 20 threads over and over?

2 Likes

Get outta here, old man! :berserker:

1 Like

Didn’t realize 35 was that old…
image

6 Likes

Your age begins with 2 squared - I think that counts.

2 Likes

Brilliant exegesis. My waist line is a power of 2. Feeling so at home here kids!

1 Like