At Brad Baker’s (Champagne Warrior), with Jim Lester, Brad Cook, Jim & Cheryl Brennan (+ kids), George Heritier, Kid Adams, Paul Ragheb, Jim Baker (Brad’s dad), and Dale Wilson. Great friends and wonderful wines. An evening to be thankful for being alive.
2009 Wyncroft Avonlea Riesling - beautiful McIntosh apple, slate, young & steely 88.
2006 Wyncroft Chardonnay - Lemond curd, mineral, austere & high acid, very young 89? 2nd bottle better fruit 92.
1986 Chartron & Trebuchet St Aubin La Chateniere - Honeyed, med bodied, smokey, faded fruit, but not oxidized, just old.
2008 Wyncroft Riesling Vendage Tardive (VT) - huge floral nose, dry honey essence, minerals & good acid, an immense and powerfull wine 95.
Despite taking private lessons from Brad baker and Brad Cook, Champagne is still not in my roundhouse, I really don’t feel like I have the ability to judge them on a 100 point scale, so out of 5 stars:
2002 Cristal - very austere, a champagne for the future? ***
1999 Cristal - Good fruit, enjoyable ****
1996 Cristal - Toasty, raspberry ****
1989 Cristal - Sweet brioche, only slightly petillant - deliscious *****
2007 Faiveley Mercury Clos des Myglands - rose petal nose, sweet fruit, a bit austere, moderate finish 87.
2006 Faiveley Mercury Clos des Myglands - a deep dark fruit nose, but green tannins and fruit lacking 80.
2006 Wyncroft Shou - amazing ringer for a Pauillac, tobacco, med bodied, good balance, not a blockbuster, but a great effort for a challenging Michigan vintage for reds 89.
2006 Bois de Boursan Chateauneuf du Pape - Sweet, weird, disjointed and hot. Another overripe CndP Grenache “fruit bomb” with no structure. 75.
1998 Pegau - dark fruit nose, wonderful balance, still has big fruit, and tannin, young 93.
2003 Pegau - Massive, sweet fruit, very new world, hardly recognizable as a Chateauneuf du Pape, but enjoyable to drink 90.
2001 Chateau Armaillac - Med bodied, good balance, lovely 89.
1995 Pape Clement - great Bordeaux! Gorgeous balance - big fuit & tannins, still very young, LONG life ahead 95.
2007 SQN Labels Syrah - Black, hugh nose that you can smell from across the room as soon as the bottle was opened (the only othr time I have every had this happen was with a 1982 Cheval Blanc), massive, but too medicinal, like a cocktail of cough syrup and Nyquil, moderate finish 89?