WsOTY -- 2024 Edition and your Discovery of the Year--TABULATIONS COMPLETE

It has for one or another reason been a year of comfort wines - less exploring new wineries/wines and more wines I have like for a longer time. Partially related to the cellar inventory reduction drive, but might also have something to do with times in general (?). Probably my worst year every in terms of taking notes, will have to correct that in 2025!

Some of the wines could be called simpler, humble or something in that direction but they have been exactly what the doctor prescribed, and more.

Red WOTY - hard pick, but today it would be in this order

  • 2015 Enderle & Moll Liaison - the Xmas bottle that was just terrific (freshest in mind as well) and shared with my brother and mother.
  • 2013 Colombera & Garella Bramaterra Cascina Cottignano - Drinking really well, fast evaporating
  • 2015 Burlotto Monvigliero - a special wine, shared with special people
  • 1996 Ronchi di Cialla Schioppettino - timeless and a special wine made by special people
  • 2019 Bartolo Mascarello Dolcetto d’Alba - A great dolcetto that drank really well
  • 2016 Milos Plavac - Singing at the moment and a singular wine, the best of Dalmatia in a bottle

White WOTY:

  • 2022 Hofgut Falkenstein Krettnacher Euchariusberg Kugel Peter - Tight upon opening, though drinking really well, AND a month later a lot more going on and just terrific!
  • 2022 Weingut Seehof Westhofener Kirchspiel Riesling trocken - loved everything about it
  • 2018 Ronchi di Cialla Ribolla Gialla - continues having that terrific drive and substance and feels like it will keep going for ages

Champagne:

  • NV Henin-Delouvin Champagne Harmonie Brut - for the price, excellent
  • Suenen Oiry BdB GC - Probably the better wine of the two but had less focus and time to follow this bottle

Since, except very minor explorations this year, I’ll add a learning of the year - Grk might not age as well as I had expected, hope. The acidity and its structure, together with the fruit profile had me thinking they would age really well. Perhaps related to the winemaking (?), as almost all are made to be enjoyed quite early.
So what has been the issue - they develop some sort of at times pronounced milky/lactic flavors, it faded a bit with one bottle (out of three), but for the other two it remained quite prominent. 2016 was the vintage. Not sure I have come across this in any other wines, and two independent producers showed this character. Lets see how they develop over the coming years, but will try some of the more recent vintages to the mix in 2025.

Discovery of the year - How good many of my favorite wines that I have had less of in previous years (in the cellar but been focused on exploring) are!

5 Likes

Will add a discovery of the year to my wines of the year posted earlier:

2023 Zeitgeist Chenin Blanc

Really tasty and everyone enjoy it. Had to go back and buy some more, which I’ve never done for a white wine (my cellar is probably 90% still red wine, as that’s what my wife and I love to drink).

2 Likes

Awesome posts @Nick_Christie - looks like quite a wine year for you sir.

3 Likes

Quite a wonderful read, Nick. Thanks for sharing that.

1 Like

OK everyone. We have absolutely shattered any previous numbers for contributions. I have our count at 937 entries by people. Bravissimo!

I will work on the tabulation tonight, but it looks like Rousseau is the clear house winner with over 20 mentions and—perhaps no surprise—2001 D’Yquem is in strong position to be wine of the year with 6 entries----the 06 Krug Clos Mesnil is just behind it with 5. I’ll do a full inventory later. Everything, as always, will be up in the OP and I will modify the title of the thread.

Because there were so many wines input this year, I will likely only list houses that got 8 or more mentions this time around (the floor for inclusion has usually been 5). Be back with all of that later. Thank you again, everyone—this is always such fun to read and put together.

Kwa Heri

Mike

12 Likes

Thanks again for doing the work, Mike.

My pleasure, Gavin, thanks. OK, all done—everything is up in the OP now. If you want, PM me with any questions on any of the other results :slight_smile:

It was, as always, fun to pull this together.

It was 06 Krug cdm right?

Yup. Sorry, I’ll correct that when I get home

With a whopping 0.006% of the votes! Clear winner! :wink: :laughing:

Great thread to read through, thanks Mike and all posters!

@Mike_Grammer, thanks for the work compiling the list. Here’s a tip. If you want your wines to make the list, share them with fellow Berserkers. In addition to the 2001 d’Yquem, each of the following got multiple votes from different Berserkers who drank them with each other (and they all made my list as well):

  • 2002 Emidio Pepe Montepulciano (!)
  • 2010 Sauzet Montrachet
  • 2018 L’Anglore Tavel Rose
  • 2005 Patty Green Notorious PN
1 Like

Yeah I mean, a bunch of the wines on the top list were from one dinner. Would’ve been likely even more if there were more than 3 berserkers there :wink:

6 Likes