OK everyone. As always, big thanks for all the contributions. Significant decrease from the record number of entries last year, I had 522 entries to work with this time.
A dessert wine reclaims top spot with 1988 D’Yquem earning 4 first-place votes.
1996 Dom, 2001 JJ Prum Wehlehner Sonnenuhr Ries Goldkapsel, 1990 Mugnier Musigny, 1988 Krug and—sort of—Selosse Initial (different disgorgements) each got 3 votes.
D’Yquem also wins for house with 12 mentions. Selosse was the only other house in double digits with 10 mentions. List of the others (as always, I won’t list any house with less than 5 mentions)
Climens (5)
Margaux (5)
Chave (6)
Dom (5)
DRC (7)
Prum (7)
Keller (German) (8)
Krug (6)
Lafon (6) (a nice comeback for them)
Mugnier (8) (definitely the most mentions ever)
Raveneau (7)
Roederer (6)
Taittinger (5)
Ulysse Collin (7)
Not surprisingly, basically no Cali cult cabs (outside of perhaps Kapscandy or MacDonald). I was surprised to see no Schrader or Maybach this year. No Lafite was the standout miss in Bordeaux (unless I missed an entry). No Emmanuel Rouget in Burgundy. No Grange, no Chapoutier and no Masseto. No Marcassin. It was nice to see Verset make it in with 4 mentions this year. With that said, I think this is the lowest number of DRC mentions I can remember. Also super-fun to see Extradimensional Wine Co Yeah come in with 2 votes.
Again, thanks to all. My own choices are below
& & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & & &
I’m sure I’ll forget to start this in a few days when I normally do, so I’ll start it now. I definitely hope to amend/add to my list before the year is out. But with fall beginning to at least show itself in the leaves changing, may as well get started. I’m pretty sure nothing is budging me from my WOTY, the 2nd perfect wine I’ve ever had in my life. As always, scores only included where my tasting note pushed me to include that.
2001 JJ Prum Wehlehner Sonnenuhr Goldkapsel Ries (96)
2005 Henri Boillot Hospice Mazis-Chambertin
1990 Nicholas Feuillatte Palme D’Or
2005 Remoissenet Batard-Montrachet
2020 Bachelet-Ramonet Chassagne La Grande Montagne
2006 Hudellot-Noellat Vosne Les Beaumonts
2017 Jadot Puligny Clos de la Garenne (93)
Fernando de Castillo Antique Oloroso Sherry
2005 Taittinger CDC Rose
1996 Guigal La Mouline
2001 Trimbach CFE VT (93)
1985 Chateau Grand Puy Lacoste
2001 Jamet Cote Rotie
1994 Zind-Humbrecht Gewurtz Rangen den Thann SGN (100 points)
2007 Chateau Rieussec
1991 Mondavi Reserve Cab
Krug NV 173
The “discovery” was probably the sherry—more of a reminder that I should definitely be having more sherry in my life!
Looking forward to everyone’s input. As usual, I will do the tabulations in the first week of January. And, if I’ve missed a WOTY thread this year that someone else may have started, please point me to it so I can add that into the calculations.
Haere Ra,
Mike