Watched it last night. Highly enjoyable! The scene where Hollywood Jeff and his pet terrier are cruising around with the bottle of La La trying to get everyone to agree how great the wine is, only to get completely shut down at the store was hilarious.
I thought the movie was very well done. The comments from Rudy’s defense counsel left me a little embarrassed to be a lawyer - I think "no comment " would have better served themselves and their client.
+1 on all accounts. I thought it was very well made.
I do think the movie convinced me that Rudy had significant help producing the fakes, which I hadn’t considered previously.
Who was ‘Christian’ in the LA store that shot down Levy & his venture cap douche friend about the La Mouline being fake?
I think there was a mixture of both. There was no doubt that Rudy was a prolific buyer of genuine wines from merchants in Europe.
But if my theory about the Patriarche wines is correct, he had a vast store of vintage correct and appellation correct wines, even if they weren’t great. Not a great stretch to imagine some modification (adding a little young wine of a particular grower to an older bottle) to provide a touch of grower identity, with the added bonus of a period correct bottle.
If you combine this with serving of genuine bottles at dinners as a ‘convincer’, well…
If you go back and re-read the entire Rudy K. thread, there was a lot of back and forth on this precise question. It was probably some combination of
real and fake, but different people have different views on what the relative %'s were and whether the relative %'s changed over time.
Most of us will have observed the power of ‘group think’ in assessing wines. It’s often fun at a tasting or dinner to see how two groups at either end of a table group think themselves to quite different opinions.
One thing that struck me in the documentary is how on tasting a wine people would immediately tell those they were with what it tasted like. Maybe even listing half a dozen types of fruit. That is not something one often observes in Europe, and I think is a catalyst for group think.
It’s not hard to see how a couple of opinionated cool aid drinkers can assert opinions that self propagate.
Well, compared to his uncles who absconded with a billion dollars worth of the Indonesian people’s money and still livin’ large… he’s a pretty sorry excuse for the family business.