Posting this partly as a follow-up to the “Who makes the best Wehlener Sonnenuhr” thread from last year, partly out of boredom while waiting for 2020 German offers…
This is focused on kabinett and spätlese for me. Was going through my tasting notes on prior wines from Graacher Himmelreich. While I started with J.J. Prüm on my overall riesling journey, and continue to enjoy its expression of the vineyard, I find myself gravitating more towards Willi Schaefer’s wines (at least in their youth, as I have only had Graacher Domprobst wines from Willi Schaefer with serious age).
I imagine these two have some of the best parcels in that vineyard, though there are other producers making excellent wines lately from there (Max Ferd Richter for example). Who do you all like, and why?
I served the Prum 2002 GH Spatlese blind to a group tonight. People were guessing a Middle Mosel five years old. This was decanted ~30 minutes ahead. It was tight, tight, tight – so young and unevolved. I think a longer decant would have helped, but there was almost nothing secondary yet. I was surprised. Prums are slow to come around, but this seems to be aging glacially. (Bought on or near release and stored at ~55F.)
I don’t expect Lieser to get as much love on here as Prum or Schaefer, but Lieser’s GH Kab is wonderful, especially the 2019. Thomas said that the GH was his favorite Kabinett of 2019.
I love the wines from Schloss Lieser and have a good bit more of them than wines from Schaefer, but I don’t think I have ever had a wine from Graach from him.
Distribution in the US isn’t great (hopefully improving now that he’s with skurnik) but I typically see a graach kabi and a GG (the latter is very much worth seeking out in my view if you like Mosel GG). I don’t know if he typically makes other non-dry wines from graach him. I don’t recall buying any but he makes so many different wines that it’s hard to keep track. He makes a graach domprobst kabi that ie brings to the auction.
For me it’s mostly Prum and Schaefer. Just don’t see/drink enough G. Himmelreich from other producers. I have had one or two from Selbach (2001 Spatlese*…mmm), but haven’t seen one around in years, while the Selbach Domprobst wines regularly show up.
Not nearly as much experience as you folks, but I like Richter nearly as much as I like Prüm. And at half the price - K&L has 2020 MFR for $20 and Prüm for $50(!), it’s become a must buy for me. A 2019 MFR GH trocken blew me away recently - I served it as an aperitif but it deserved far more attention.
I bought a case and a half of assorted Prüm last year but questioning if I’ll buy much at all this year.
Loosen’s Stablay parcel in that vineyard is worth seeking out. Southwest facing, 100 year old ungrafted vines. Loosen used to bottle this separately from his regular GH. Different AP number. For me, it’s always by far been the best Cab/Spat wine in their portfolio. Great acidity in that wine, even in a so-so vintage like 1999. Sadly, that vineyard is not being bottled separately anymore. I have 2001, 2005 375s, and 2008 Spatlese. '05 was bottled exclusively for French Laundry. '08 for Wild Ginger in Seattle. A close friend started the US sales operation for Loosen Bros. That’s how I was able to get the '05 and '08.
Wild Ginger’s wine list as of Dec. 2019 had '08 and '12 Stablay Spat on their list.
At what age do you drink the wines? Not an expert on Richter’s wines, but Prum’s wines really shine with a good bit of age. If you are planning to drink them young, I really don’t think of either Prum or Schaefer as a great winery to purchase wines from. Kind of like buying Latour and drinking it at 3 years old. Probably tastes good, but you are missing a lot.