My wife always appreciates sparkling rose on Valentines. Billecart-Salmon NV rose is pretty accessible and always delivers (albeit maybe $10 above your range).
One of my selection criteria ( not the only one) is grower champagnes and looking for Skurnik import on the back label. Usually pretty good, and many < $75
Gabe, whatever you decide, I’d be interested and enjoy hearing about which one you pick, and how it turned out for you and your lady after next weekend. Have a great dinner.
Since it sounds like the OP is not broadly versed in Champagne, I think the 244 is a safe bet. Its a fine example of a classically styled, big house Champagne.
It looks like they don’t have any in stock, but both Thatcher’s and WHWC have Egly-Ouriet Les Prémices for about $65 and I think it’s the best Champagne under $75. I’d pick it up for next time.
Thanks for the recommendation! Popped open the bottle of Vilmart for Valentine’s Day. This was clearly a level above what we have tasted in the past. That was made clear with the first sip. The champagne had a sense of elegance and sharpness. We both commented on the acidity and it making our mouth water. Nectarine, green apple and lime on the palate with a minerality finish. We are new to the world of champagne but excited to begin trying more (my wallet might hate me though).