TN: Two Older Calif Rhones (Garretson/Alban)...(short/boring)

These two were brought as mystery wines at ystrday’s tasting at Pig+Fig of Harrington Wines:

  1. GarretsonWineCompany TheReliquary CentralCoast (15.2%; 67% Syrah/20% Grenache/8% Mourvedre/5% Viognier) PasoRobles 2001: Very dark color w/ some browning; strong Grenache/strawberry very strong blackberry/Syrah rather toasty/smokey/Fr.oak classic very ripe/Paso/Syrah bit alcoholic slight cedary/pencilly some complex nose; soft rather alcoholic/fumey very ripe/Syrah/boysenberry strong toasty/smokey/oak loads of fruit slightly complex flavor w/ light/drying tannins; very long finish that mimics the flavor; still loads of very ripe/overripe Syrah fruit that you wouldn’t expect from a 22 yr old Paso Syrah; interesting that it survived this long under a Neo-Cork.

  1. AlbanVnyds Grenache EdnaVlly AlbanEstate (15.3%) 2002: Very dark/near black color w/ some bricking on the edges; very intense blackberry/strawberry/Grenache/boysenberry strong toasty/charred/burnt/Fr.oak very youthful/licorice huge fruit bit complex/smokey nose; slightly tart intense boysenberry/ripe/strawberry/Grenache very youthful/huge Grenache fruit rather toasty/charred/Fr.oak w/ modest chewey tannins; very long/lingering very intense Grenache/strawberry/boysenberry slight peppery very strong toasty/charred/Fr.oak finish w/ modest chewey/hard tannins; still a huge amount of very ripe Grenache fruit & loads of charred oak; the hard/chewey tannins have moderating some but that is about all.

More pitterblost from TheBloodyPulpit:

  1. Garretson: Now there’s a name associated w/ Rhones you don’t hear much anymore. Mat was a wine retailer down in Atlanta & fell in love w/ Condrieu and the Viognier grape. He then founded TheViognier Guild and organized a get-together in Atlanta of Viognier producers. I was not invited.
    He then went on to become marketing director at EberleWnry in PasoRobles. The 2’nd ViognierGuild meeting was held there in Paso at EberleWnry. I was not invited. He became good friends w/ Viognier-producer JohnAlban and they organized the 3’rd ViognierGuild meeting there in Paso. I was not invited.
    Because many of the Viognier producers were keeping btls of their Reds under the table to pour to tasters, the name of the next mtg was changed to RaisenRhones. I was finally invited. I still have my RaisenRhones nametag that I pull out to impress people with & wear to various wine events. It was held at the Paso FairGrounds. Another RaisenRhones was held & I again was invited.
    The name was once again changed, with Mat & John as the organizers, to Hospices du Rhone. And the rest, as they say, is history. All described in PatrickComisky’s book on the US Rhone movement, an outstanding read. I still have several of the Viognier Guild glasses used at those early meetings.
    Mat then went on to bigger things & became marketing director at Kenny Volk’s WildHorseWnry, where he started dabbling at winemaking. He then went on to found the GarretsonWineCompany, making wine in a warehouse facility w/ AugieHug across the highway from MartinBrosWnry.
    Mat’s wines were always huge/extracted/oaked/alcoholic monsters, a la JohnAlban and ManfredKrankl. They showed huge fruit upon release. But they didn’t age particularly. He then switched to the StuYaniger’s (another name you don’t hear much of anymore) plastic NeoCork. This was a failed science experiment and most wines put up under NeoCork failed at any early age. As did Mat’s. He then eventually switched to screw-tops, which worked just fine for aging.
    This Reliquary was brought by LarryArchibald and put up under Neo-Cork. It showed huge fruit, but no signs of oxidation as you’d expect from an old Neo-Cork wine. However, the next day , sitting out opened on the counter, the wine had turned a murky brown, showed lots of cedary/pencilly/oldRed/oxidized character and was pretty much dead&gone.

  1. Alban: This is a pretty typical old Alban Grenache. The retain their intense fruit forever and age at a glacial pace. This one is still very youthful and in no danger of falling apart. That said, they seldom develop the complexity & perfume that an old Ojai/Qupe/EdmundsStJohn/TablasCreek would routinely develop. I’m not quite sure what is the point of making a monolithic red wine that lives forwver. Other then when you can taste it young and note that this wine will live forever. At least that’s the way it works in Monktown.
    Thanks to Steve Sterbenz for bring the Alban.
    Tom
7 Likes

I tasted Cris Cherry’s first rendition of his wonderful Villa Creek Avenger from barrel at Mat’s warehouse. I always liked Mat and his wines and was sorry when he ceased operations. And I’m still a big fan of Cris Cherry and his Villa Creek wines.

Any chance you will be heading to Walla Walla for HdR 2024?

Pretty unlikely, Mel.
Tom

1 Like

Garretson was my gateway/ entry level when I first started to be interested in wine. Loved the huge flavors and the cool Gaelic labels. Still love the labels……
Got to meet Mat once at a tasting in Scottsdale and thought he was a great guy.
Hope he’s happy and successful in whatever he’s up to now.

A little background on the Reliquary: I had opened it two nights before to go with Laura’s potatoes-and-sausage creation but was a little put off when I opened it – pretty noticeable VA, which if I remember correctly was not unusual with Mat’s wines – and not quite good enough. So I put the cork back in, figuring I could take it to Tom’s tasting for the edification of a larger group. (Its replacement was a 1987 Silverado Reserve cab about which I also had my reservations, but it turned out to be really good, both the night it was opened and the following night).

At Tom’s tasting the Reliquary had changed a bit. I noticed some mild oxidation/old-red-wine character on both the nose and the palate, but the VA was gone. I was surprised when most people liked it! I liked it a bit, and was really surprised that it was at all drinkable, given what some of Mat’s wines did with age, but overall was happy not to have other bottles in the cellar.

1 Like

haven’t heard Stu Yaniger’s name in a long time…My wife and I had dinner with Stu at Spiedini’s in Walnut Creek…Not sure when but it might well have been at least 15-20 years ago, if not longer.

Bringing back some great memories there, my friend. Those Alban Grenaches certainly are ‘substantial’ and I think I’ve had better luck seeing those tannins integrate a bit better than you. Grenache can certainly be a ‘tricky’ variety to work with, having a surprising level of tannins that needs to be tamed. Perhaps John has understood this better since those early releases?

And one of my favorite Garretson memories is meeting him when I was collecting samples for my Masters work. He donated bottles of his current syrah releases and I purchased a couple of other bottles, including one of his roses. I brought a bottle to an event on campus where I had brought in Daryl Corti to be the speaker. Daryl sat next to me for the casual dinner afterwords and shared some fantastic sparkling Shiraz from Seppeltz as well as some aged Aussie Semillon. I brought out the rose - which was probably 15+% - and Daryl took one sip, looked at me, poured the glass out, and moved on . . .

Great memories . . .

We bought a case of the rosé every year and somehow we sucked down a bottle at dinner and when I went to stand up… looked at the bottle at yup 15+

Weren’t Mat’s wines bottled with a different type of synthetic cork rather than a Neocork? I seem to recall Garretson corks being much denser than Neocorks, so perhaps that’s why the wine in your bottle survived as long as it did.

You’re right, Ken. They were those hard/dense corks. Had the same problem, though.
Tom

1 Like

I think maybe SupremeCorq? Although, he may have used two synthetic closures from two different producers before switching to screwcaps.

-Al

1 Like