2013 White Burgundy Tasting with the monthly group. This was an interesting one for me for a couple of reasons.
- First, I really didn’t like 2013 compared to other recent white burg vintages - to me, they were excessively green and lacked the kind of density I look for. This tasting reconfirmed that for me - some pretty wines, but not my thing.
- Second, boy did I fall hard for the ringer.
Order from Group’s First to Last
Paul Pillot Chassagne Montrachet 1er Les Grands Ruchottes - Group’s 1st (29 points), my 2nd. Easily the best wine on the table in any sort of objective sense - with a ton of chalk and density. Lip-smacking, which is what I like in my white burgs. Chalk, chalk, chalk, and lots of extract. I don’t rank this first because it has a ton of sulfur - even 3 hours after it was opened, the nose is impenetrably sulfury. But this has a ton of promise if it doesn’t fry. I wrongly assumed this was a PYCM.
Francis Carillon Puligny Montrachet 1er Les Perrieres - Group’s 2nd (36 points), my 3rd. Lovely bottle. Classic nose of lemon curd, French oak. This has a fairly rich midpalate but enough chalk and extract so that it doesn’t get sloppy. Lemony and delicious.
Domaine Ramonet Chassagne Montrachet - Group’s 3rd (41 points), my 6th. Very green, almost grassy. Minty. I had (correct) suspicions about this bottle. Lemon fruit and some chalk on the finish. Too green for my taste but I can see why this would be a very nice wine for some.
Pierre Yves Colin-Morey Chassagne Montrachet Les Ancegnieres - Group’s 4th (46 points), my 7th. Green, minty nose, more green apple than lemon. Touch of cream. Oddly soft and short on the palate - missing the back half of the wine. Not enough oomph for me.
Paul Pernot Puligny Montrachet 1er Clos de Folatieres - Group’s 5th (50 points), my 5th. Whoa?! Flamboyant! Tropical, ripe. Papaya, passion fruit, some lemon. Whoa is this ripe. Even a touch alcoholic. A little more oak than some. I wrote down “Is this a ringer?” Was stunned to learn this was the Pernot. Probably would be the best wine in a CA tasting as a ringer but seems out of place here. Everyone seemed to agree that this had a very unusual profile. Across the board, I’ve had bad or odd 2013’s from Pernot.
Chantereves Chassagne Montrachet 1er Morgeot - Group’s T6th (51 points), my 4th. Holy cow, is this appley. I wrote down “green apple like a laser!” Good but very simple - this is missing extract and minerality, its tasty but its very clean/fruit focused. Some of that may be the vineyard - never liked Morgeot for whites. A touch green.
Domaine Hudelot-Baillet Hautes Cotes de Nuits - Group’s T6th (51 points), my 8th. Anonymous, high acid. Lemon vinagrette. John Morris snarks that I don’t like high acid whites (which stings a little more after the next reveal). Perhaps. Tastes like muscadet.
RINGER Domaine Carneros La Terre Promise Vineyard 2013 - Group’s 8th (56 points), my 1st. Oops. I thought, “finally, a 2013 that doesn’t taste like a 2013”. Indeed. Less green than the others. Lemon and cream on the nose, some oak but not over the top. Broader midpalate. Salty finish. I thought there was plenty of acid here, but others suggested maybe acidified. Not my finest hour.