I was fortunate enough to taste a 16 vintage vertical of Chave recently (rouge and blanc) and this was my second favorite vintage (1990 was the best for me - finally tasted a good one)…a classic interpretation of the grape, terroir, and producer and entering a good spot IMO.
I did sense that some of the newer vintages were more ripe and fruit forward - hard to tell if it was a change in the style of the wines and/or climate change…The 2003 was roasted and undrinkable.
I would love to try and make that! Been bringing '90s back East over last couple of years and need to double check what I have left. Brad; I have some '90 left from the same batch that showed so well at your house last summer.
Just saw this, sorry. Hopefully John will chime in, too, but I doubt he’ll see it.
The ‘07 Gonon St Joseph was so delicious, I was saving that last bottle to have with John, knowing how much he loves Syrah, and particularly Northern Rhone. It didn’t disappoint, and had the perfect mouthfeel and structure to go with the (somewhat spicy) carne asada, though I’m not sure I’d call it a perfect pairing, though that’s likely because the carne asada was spicier than Master Favre had with his freakin’ Chave. Just enough freshness to the fruit, in its early secondary stage, and a huge dose of iron/blood/iodine.
I also broke out an '01 Chapoutier Cornas, and it was the best of the bottles I had enjoyed (5 in all to date) - in a GREAT space right now. Meaty like crazy, lighter bodied than the Gonon, but spot on delicious.