That Single Bottle

The theme of last night’s Monday Table was ‘Single Bottle’. Michael instructed us to bring ‘that single bottle’ that has been rattling around in our cellars, looking for an event to attend. The resultant night was epic.

1971 Piper-Heidsieck Champagne Hors-Série: Disgorged February 2021. Complex notes of toast, truffle, brioche and vanilla. Great intensity, power and drive. Still fine of bead and creamy of mousse. A super salty finish persists for a long time.

1911 Moët & Chandon Champagne Grand Vintage Collection: Bottle number 156 of 200 released. Disgorged in January 2011. Sadly, just a touch of mouldiness from the cork distracts from a special old wine. Still a bit of prickle from remaining bubbles. Some rancio and cheesy things along with Autumnal leaves and truffle. There’s a nutty/aldehyde volatility. It has something sweet and vinous at its heart. Vanilla spice with air. Chalky finish. What a treat to try.

2004 Remoissenet Père et Fils Le Montrachet, Grand Cru : Pineapple, smoky mineral and sappy orchard fruits. Voluminous and layered. Loads of spice and very long.

1997 Remoissenet Père et Fils Le Montrachet, Grand Cru . Again, freshly cut pineapple here along with some mango. Smoky reduction, menthol and heady blossom scents too. Good depth, layers of flavour. Finishes with detail and is long and expansive. A very good ’97 white.

2016 Domaine Coche-Dury Corton-Charlemagne, Grand Cru : Very tight and youthful, emitting but a bare whiff of smoky mineral and citrus blossom. The palate is built around a rigid, steely spine. It has fabulous intensity of pure white peach and lemon fruits. It is precise, stony, cool and finishes with such authority and drive. Wonderful wine with so much more in the tank.

2022 Domaine de la Romanée-Conti Corton-Charlemagne, Grand Cru : Rich, opulent and heady. Coconut ice, vanilla, ripe peach, fig, brown spices and candied citrus. So deep, layered and power. Waves of flavour lap around the gums. The finish draws in and is precise, with length to burn.

1990 Domaine de la Romanée-Conti La Tâche, Grand Cru : This is right in the zone. A gorgeous, highly perfumed nose draws you in. Notes of Hoisin, smoked meats, rose petals and aniseed. It is ethereal and silky and possesses real latent power. Nothing is forced. It builds through the palate, fans out and keeps going. A great La Tâche.

1999 Faiveley Musigny, Grand Cru: Bottle number 143 of 149 produced. Still such a deep, vivid colour. Has a core of luscious, liqueur cherry. There are gorgeous purple flower florals and a hint of earth. It is full, rich and opulent, but with a cool stony base. There’s a wonderful line of fine, minerally acidity and length is imposing. Superb wine.

1929 Bouchard Père et Fils Beaune 1er Cru Teurons : A recent acquisition, direct from the Bouchard cellars. Starts off with some nutty aldehyde and earth and then really builds in the glass. It has vinous sweetness and seaweed saltiness. There’s a strand of licorice too. It is thick and unctuous through the mid-palate and has great presence and silky feel. Length is outstanding.

1945 Seguin-Manuel Charmes-Chambertin, Grand Cru: So gorgeously perfumed. Light florals, sweet earth and smoked meats. Lacy and layered, vital and detailed. Good volume and dimension and everything is in place. A beautiful, aged Burg at its apogee.

1959 Maison Leroy Grands-Echezeaux, Grand Cru: Meat and leather dominate early and it is a little bretty. There are things of joy that appear with air. Dried flowers, Chinese 5 spice and soy. It is full and velvety with a sweet, vinous centre. Structural elements still support and it is expansive.

1962 Jaboulet-Vercherre Musigny, Grand Cru: Not showing a lot on first pour. Earth and mineral things appear with air and then black cherry fruit concentrates at the core. It has Musigny’s cool cherry stone elements and a lusciousness to the palate. There are savoury/tertiary things that add complexity. It is in a great place and is satisfying and long.

1900 Château Branaire Ducru, Saint-Julien: There’s just a touch of tca here that distracts. Behind the taint there is something vital and complex. Briary fruits, ginger and Indian spices. Really textural and layered. Black olive saltiness.

1928 Château Desmirail, Margaux: A mid-weight, nicely balanced wine of cassis and sweet cedar notes. It has some leather and earth and is still fresh and energetic.

1953 Château Margaux: A perfumed and engaging bottle of Claret. Violets, cedar, tobacco and blackberries. Subtle earthy tones. Elegance with presence. Each sip unlocks something interesting. Fine acid cut and a gentle flex of muscle from the tannins at the tail.

1866 Quinta do Vallado Porto Adelaide Tributa Port: Incredibly complex and sweet. Burnt figs, honey, raisins chocolate and Indian spices. Almost a sweet Muscat feel to it. So rich and layered. Cut with a beautiful spirit. Wonderful volume and presence and really long.

Explorer Liqueur Muscat (bottled 1974): This had a fair bit of 1800’s Rutherglen Muscat in it and boy is it good. Dried fig and raisins, toffee, cola and blackberries. Layered, sweet and intense. Heady spirit contributes florals. Great complexity and incredible palate staining concentration. Length for days.

1893 Barnet & Fils Fine Cognac Champagne: Spirity and Cognacy (sorry, it was getting late).

41 Likes

Blimey! That’s brilliant - imagine having bottles like those lurking in a corner of your cellar !

1 Like

What a remarkable night, but so so many wines, each of which would be worth lingering over. While the wow factor of a night like that is undeniable, I can’t help feeling something is lost as well.

1 Like

It’s Jeremy, what else would you expect?!?

A big wow for sure!

1 Like

!!!

Some twenty years ago I opened a 1947 Seguin-Manuel Charmes along with a Denis Bachelet 1992. Weirdly the wines were almost indistinguishable, and memorably delicious.

2 Likes

Incredible lineup. But I can’t believe your group was so impatient with these 2 — couldn’t wait for century mark???

1 Like

What a fantastic idea, and the only way to make ‘that one special bottle’ more special is to get together with many others and multiply it by X!!

7 Likes

Hi Bill, I understand what you are saying but let me add the following.

A menu was designed by the host and executed well by the chef to compliment each bracket perfectly. We had a quick look at each bracket blind and spoke about the wines. The wines were then unveiled, and the contributor of each wine spoke about their offering giving information about the wine and its origin. We spent ample time on each wine, tasting and discussing and a couple of the wines that I thought would really befit from more air, I set aside and re-visited an hour or so later. The group is made up of like-minded wine lovers who have become dear friends. We genuinely enjoy each other’s company and there is a generous spirit and real fellowship around the table. All wines were shared with the chef and two Somms and you could sense their excitement and appreciation. A few of us have been around the vinous block a bit but we always learn at such dinners and yesterday there was still back and forth discussion after the event between as few of us, still talking about the wines from Monday night.

My contribution for the night was the Coche CC. In return, I got to try all of those other wonderful wines. Was it a waste? Hell no! Would I have enjoyed it on its own at home? Of course I would have. There are many ways us ‘wine nerds’ enjoy our wines. With my friends at Monday Table is one way I do and at home with my family is another.

Kind regards
Jeremy

14 Likes

I think the early prediction market for the Golden Urine Award is leaning toward Jeremy and his mates for 2026!

3 Likes

It was right up there for wine of the night honours, in a strong field.

1 Like

Was Single Bottle (Club?) not a Len Evans thing? I seem to remember a large chest with many small drawers (like a Duclot Collection Caisse) with each drawer containing the menu and corks from different SBC dinners…?

Hmmmm…thanks for the TNs. I did not keep any of two 1990 DRC monopole…so very happy to read this kind of TNs. Sad,but I do enjoy very much LT from the so, so years for example 1992, 994..etc..as they were not that painful to share with your friends.

Merci… Jeremy - keep it up. Life should be enjoyed to its fullest. Do not face the moon with your golden empty glass : so said the Wine God of China. 李白 LI Bat - more than 1000 years ago !!


李白
See how the Yellow River’s waters move out of heaven.
Entering the ocean, never to return.
See how lovely locks in bright mirrors in high chambers,
Though silken-black in the morning, it has changed by night to snow.
…Oh, let a man of spirit venture where he pleases
And never tip his golden cup empty toward the moon!
… ****

2 Likes

Lovely comments and very happy to read them.

When I was young at my young wine life. We did once in while to hold a wine-event under the Theme : Is Parker’s 100 points best to enjoy ???

All the wines were from Bordeaux and all the wines were rated 100 points by Parker in WA.

Normally at the end of the event, we ended up agreeing that Parker is right - all of them were indeed 100 points.

Later on we found any win-event, is better off by drinking Burgundy wines which were seldom ( or never ) rated by Parker ( in WA )…100%.

We loved those events…as we were arguing why the burgundy wines were never rated perfect ( or higher ) by Parker - for example most of red from vintage 1993.

Just posted on a lone soldier opened last night here: What bottle of wine did you open today? (Part 2) - #10736 by Neal.Mollen

Yes Matthew, Len used to run a single bottle club.

Glad I’m not dreaming it!

You did nicely on those Remoissenet Montys. I’ve seen lots of pox there. Got Bernie to replace a fair bit with younger vintages but he was in massive denial that his wines showed any premature oxidation.

1 Like

I gave up on buying G-cru whites due to pox, long ago. SAQ by policy, does not refund any whites which are pox stating that when the bottles were sold they were not yet pox - and which I agree.

SAQ refunds any bottle which is cooked with a receipt.