Quilceda vs. Bordeaux?

Hi all,

First post on WB. I joined the waiting list for Quilceda a few years ago and finally got an an offer for their 2018 Cabernet at $145 before shipping. I’ve never had one but understand that they’re excellent. But for about that kind of money, you could get a very nice Margaux or Pauillac. Is Quilceda really that good and worthwhile? And for those of you who have great experiences with them, are there situations or food pairings when you’d reach for a Quilceda cab before a Bordeaux? Many thanks in advance for your guidance and opinions.

Mike

3 Likes

I have a decent amount of Quilceda in my cellar. I’d rather have Bordeaux.

1 Like

Quilceda is biggie big WA cab
If u like other biggie big WA cabs you will like quilceda.
It’s got lots of fruit and flavor and intensity.

Quilceda was good 2000 and prior. I am a huge Washington State fan but Quilceda is way down on the list. Over the top style.

1 Like

I prefer Bordeaux too, although Quilceeda can be excellent in very small doses. Certainly fun to drink but as it is big and ripe like a lot of its Napa cousins in the South, you’ll get less nuances, less complexity than with a Bordeaux. I hardly ever would have the urge to drink a whole bottle of it, I much prefer Bordeaux from a good vintage.

The only place, where Quilceeda (and all its cousins) work just perfectly (and very often better than Bordeaux), is with a big piece of grilled meat with a smokey crust. That’s just a match made in heaven and a purley hedonistic (less so intelectual) experience.

1 Like

Mike, that’s about as highly a subjective question as you can ask! Knowing the preferences of this Board (in general), you’re going to get a lot of direction to Bordeaux. That might be great advice, but we have zero idea what your palate is like and what wines you really like right now. That might make replies more meaningful.

The answer is to try both and decide where your own personal preferences lie.

For what it’s worth, I enjoy both and it really comes down to what I’m pairing it with. Quilceda is a “big” wine, meaning it’s high extraction, high alcohol, high ripeness, which produces a very full bodied wine that can be a challenge to pair with food, but I often find can be enjoyable all on its own (nothing to smother). Much of the left bank Bordeaux producers produce something more in the medium to medium plus body, with less ripeness and alcohol, but often more earthiness and complexity, which makes it a lot better with a range of foods.

I’m picking up a bottle of the Quilceda from this latest release - it’s a well made wine in a specific style that I enjoy from time to time. I’ll also pick up some great. Bordeaux wines this year too, as there were a lot of great 2019 wines.

1 Like