Official Costco Thread

Just finished it off, about four hours after opening. It seemed well-made, elegant and in-balance but also seemingly closed down and lacking some stuffing versus other recent vintages. Cedar, blackcurrant, bramble, tobacco, stony minerality - but it never really opened up on either nose or palate.

My Bordeaux experience is relatively limited, especially with lighter vintages, but I do think could turn out nicely with some time, in a non-blockbuster way.

3 Likes

They are about 50% worse wines than 2019’s though. Those prices still are too much for 2021 Bdx.

4 Likes

That’s what I was thinking. I have a fair amount of 2018, 2019 and 2020, the pricing on 2021 is not compelling for the quality, even at the Costco reduced level.

2 Likes

Definitely still room for reductions. I picked up a '20 LLC for cheaper from Costco.

1 Like

I thought I remember something about WA laws that make discounting more difficult, but I could be making that up

Yep, im with you! At least they’re getting closer to the price-point where i might take a flier. It wasn’t even a conversation previously.

1 Like

Having been to 2021 vintage EP, there are some
Diamonds in the rough if price is right. Right would be fine ~ ‘19 release prices for some but poor for super majority.

‘21 is also an earlier drinker than many others on either side of the vintage.

If ~10 wines get to EP ‘19 release pricing they are worth picking up as those same wines in the ‘19 vintage are now more expensive.

Caveat- if you feel prices will drop further due to economy and overall wine market (which they may) then that is something to consider…

1 Like

Picked up the last 2 bottles at Los Feliz. Haven’t had D’issan before.

1 Like

Ryan, thanks for your insight. Did you happen to try 2021 Leoville Barton, and if so, do you have an opinion about it?

I have tried few in bottle so all my comments are still EP. Yes tried the 500++ wines, Barton family included. My quick notes have LB listed as average for the vintage BUT average beats out a lot of the ‘better wines’ if that makes sense. With that said, spend a little more and get it from better vintages and a 15-20% swing for that wine is ~$15 to $30.

My ratings/opinions are not based on or for my palate rather in general without context to vintage as I never understand why the critics do that. If it’s Sh-t but a top wine for the vintage, I would rate it as Sh-t vs a higher score as they re-scale it for a poor vintage. That’s dumb.

1 Like

Confirmed. You are making that up. :joy:

Figured out what I was mis-remembering. It was about dumping at below cost.

I spoke to the GM at our Costco who told me that Tennessee has a similar law.

Haven’t had much experience with Riesling so took advantage of new stock at the Boca Raton Costco a couple of weeks ago to give it a whirl.

4 Likes

The sun dial. One of my favorite vineyards I’d be all over that one

1 Like

That’s exactly right.

The Sonnenuhr (“Sundial”) vineyard is a precipitously steep, rocky site that consistently yields some of the most elegant white wines in the world. Spätlese (“late-picked”) indicates a deeply flavored wine from very ripe grapes.

(www.drloosen.com)

1 Like

Selbach Oster does a really good job with this site too.

2 Likes

JJ Prum has a few years under its belt there too. :wink:

Surprised to see back label explanation of Spätlese as indicating “a deeply flavored wine from very ripe grapes.” Not how I would describe it. Costco’s shelf-talker from winemaker makes much more sense.

3 Likes

2020 Sociando-Mallet in Santa Rosa.

2 Likes

Dang, I’m saving 2 for semi-special occasions. I assume you bought them all? Of course, who knows how they’ve been treated in the last 20+ years…