Love for Gary Farrell?

Hi everyone-

Just wondering why there is so little talk of Gary Farrell here on WineBerserkers. I ask because I’m looking to expand my Sonoma experience a bit and I find myself wondering if this a winery to seek out for great values or is it not talked about because the wines aren’t widely considered very good? They get fruit from some real top all star Sonoma vineyards (Allen, Rochioli, Bacigalupi, Ritchie, Durrell, etc).

So why not more love?

Thanks!
Noah

It’s a good question. I’m definitely not the guy to provide the answer. When I was getting into wine back in the early/mid 90’s, he was a Wine Spectator darling and it was very hard to find his wines. Not sure about now.

Noah,
My only recent experience is with a couple of the 2019 Pinots; neither of which I want again.

1 Like

Well…that’s pretty much all I need to hear.

Farrell sold the winery around 2004 and stepped away, started Alysian, which didn’t last too long.

I’ve never had a bad wine from that winery, but they don’t stand out to me.

1 Like

Never loved them. Fine, but not memorable.

1 Like

The recent 2021-2023 were all over LB and FB, particularly available during recentmarathons around 30ish. A 2023 still avail on LB

Still enjoyable wines. Worth the discounted prices.
Gary has been gone a long, long time and the raps are still reference him like he’s still there. He must have been amazing. And the wines are still pretty good.

Lots of pretty lukewarm responses here. Is it the winemaking? The general style? Vineyard sources seems great..

I have one of his AVA pinots sitting on my scant shelf for that varietal but I haven’t opened it yet. I suspect it’ll be satisfying for someone who doesn’t focus focus on that grape the way that some of you do.

The last few years the label has been blown out at Costco Whole Foods and other local regional banners.