I love Mike and Jay along with the wines at Carlisle. My wife does like them at all anymore. We’ve shifted the zin dollars to Scherrer and Hartford Family. I still buy the SC Carlisle at retail now for when she is at book club.
Damn, totally forgot about Hartford for some reason - GREAT call! Their zins have crept up into the upper echelon for me sitting alongside Bedrock, Carlisle, Ridge, and Once & Future
Bedrock
Ridge
Carlisle
I spread the above around all the vineyards but make sure to always get some Ridge Lytton Springs & Geyserville.
The above probabally puts my personal budget pretty close to $1K, who am I kidding I’m sure it is over that. I might toss in some Turley or Limerick Lane but I’d be at $2K pretty fast.
You have met the requirements - Welcome to Wineberserkers!
Your topic is very interesting. I think of myself as a zinfandel connoisseur. But zinfandel represents less than 3% of my cellar and nowhere near the financial commitment that you seem to be making on it. In fairness, I was much more interested in zinfandel 5-10 years ago, and the fact that I’ve given up on so many producers as too big or not my style is the reason that I own/spend low amounts on it today. As others have mentioned, Carlisle and Scherrer are names worth looking into that aren’t on your list. I would suggest getting on the Scherrer mailing list, inquire about older bottles for sale, and if you are so inclined, also buy a futures mixed case of their OMV and Shale Terrace, assuming you are willing to hold them for a few years before drinking. Ridge is definitely worth seeking out, both younger and older bottles to give you persepective.