FS: 2017 & 2018 Arnoux-Lachaux

[CraigT]

“State the price you are asking clearly” or send to auction if you think that will maximize your return.

[jason_stein]

“State the price you are asking clearly” or send to auction if you think that will maximize your return.

“NO public comments about pricing or the thread author’s offer on the forum - if you have a comment, criticism, or offer to make, take it to PM, not here.”

[Greg_K]

The key factor of all of the discussions about prices on this forum is that neither the transactions nor even bids are mandatory. If you don’t like Jason’s price or his method of selling the wines, you neither have to request to purchase them nor comment on his price, especially given the forum guidelines.

[Juliec]

I don’t believe that any poster has commented on pricing or offer as the OP did not set a price. I do believe that posters were trying to keep the market fair. Efficient market hypothesis. Thank you to the OP and the posters.

[Mike_C1]

Please also note the other guideline in the sticky:

It is strongly recommended that all negotiation takes place as part of the thread, not by email or private message.

And given OP’s desire (emphasis mine):

I love these wines, but considering the current market for these wanted to test the waters.

So think OP has gotten what he has bargained for.

[TBurklow]

My bid is $1500. Pm if interested.

[Will_F]

“State the price you are asking clearly” or send to auction if you think that will maximize your return.

“NO public comments about pricing or the thread author’s offer on the forum - if you have a comment, criticism, or offer to make, take it to PM, not here.”

How can I comment on pricing if you don’t have a price.

[Nick_Gangas]

The shark is officially jumped.

[Mark_Golodetz]

Is no price a price?

[Mark_Y]

I’m not sure that original cost is the right basis to consider here.

Since you’re taking offers, and original cost is not the right basis… - should we value it based on quality?

I’ve tasted most of those wines (not the Fin). Based on relative quality with other burgundies. they’re worth about… $2,000 for the lot.

[Justin_Bonner]

I’d be willing to trade you some of Tremblay’s 17 and 18 Bourgogne, village and 1er Cru offerings. I have most/all of her cuvées so feel free to make me an offer based on what you have.

[Bertrand_Leulliette]

It looks like some of these bottles are finally hitting the auction market and the prices, although stratospheric are much lower than the retail prices we are seeing out there.

[ybarselah]

lotta butthurt guys here pissed that OP has some sick wines that are super expensive, wants to sell them, and y’all don’t like it.

[patrick_c_albright]

Drank a bottle of 17 Vosne today at 70€ - easy pass.
Sell, sell, sell.

[Greg_K]

Drank a bottle of 17 Vosne today at 70€ - easy pass.
Sell, sell, sell.

I had that wine in France in October, and if you have any to sell at 70 Euro, I’ll take every bottle. Including in France - can arrange for delivery.

[Keith_A_k_e_r_s]

lotta butthurt guys here pissed that OP has some sick wines that are super expensive, wants to sell them, and y’all don’t like it.

^this.

I don’t get why anyone feels the need to comment if they aren’t actually interested. Sadly, this was expected on this forum and my only critique would be that Jason may have been better served offering them up in other places on the interwebz

[lucaslabelle]

It looks like some of these bottles are finally hitting the auction market and the prices, although stratospheric are much lower than the retail prices we are seeing out there.

Link?

[patrick_c_albright]

Drank a bottle of 17 Vosne today at 70€ - easy pass.
Sell, sell, sell.

I had that wine in France in October, and if you have any to sell at 70 Euro, I’ll take every bottle. Including in France - can arrange for delivery.

It was on the table at a restaurant.
There is plenty of back vintage Arnoux on wine lists around France.

[patrick_c_albright]

lotta butthurt guys here pissed that OP has some sick wines that are super expensive, wants to sell them, and y’all don’t like it.

whatever.

i have imported at least thirty cases of the '18’s for clients and i bought quite a bit myself.
there is plenty of wine out there.

[Greg_K]

Drank a bottle of 17 Vosne today at 70€ - easy pass.
Sell, sell, sell.

I had that wine in France in October, and if you have any to sell at 70 Euro, I’ll take every bottle. Including in France - can arrange for delivery.

It was on the table at a restaurant.
There is plenty of back vintage Arnoux on wine lists around France.

Back vintage Arnoux is very different wine.