I hesitated to post this, and wanted to make sure I lay out the nuance. I’m fan and a supporter of Mike’s wines. I have a lot of them in my cellar.
2014 Quivet Cellars Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley - USA, California, Napa Valley (2/20/2017)
So, my tastes are changing. This is excellent, obviously extremely well-made wine. We’ve tasted with Mike Smith, the winemaker. I have a lot of his wine in the cellar. I appreciate his work and his rather prolific accomplishments.
That said, this was sweet before my tastes started changing. And now, it basically tastes chocolate sweet to me. Mike’s wines are the sweetest non-desert wines in my cellar. My wife loves his style and I generally still enjoy it, but it’s less for me than it used to be.
Big, rich, voluptuous, decadent. Mike described it as pillowy. It’s soft not muscular. But there are layers and structure, it is just soft. And SWEET.
When I asked Mike why he makes wines with this approach, he answered, simply “because I think that’s what people want.” I get that completely.
I’m not going to score this, because it’s not his (or the wine’s) fault I’ve taken great interest in Pinot and white wines, and have started to enjoy grace and elegance and understatement. They are not mutually exclusive of course, but this particular wine has become a bit too much for me.
Posted from CellarTracker
Now, a couple days before this wine, we drank Mike’s 2014 Becklyn Sauv Blanc. We found it lower in alcohol, edgier, and NOT a fruit bomb like we may have expected. I find that I particularly enjoy Mike’s white wines. I will also continue buying his reds, because, well, happy wife, happy life!