One is humbled by such things… Blind tasting!
10 of us got together for our 15th blind tasting and it was my turn to host again (I hosted the 1st one). It was my intention to make this interesting and educational rather than trying to confuse everyone.
While almost everyone guessed that first flight was burgundy I don’t think anyone guessed Villages. All 3 burgundies showed well and were very site specific, Puligny was well balance and most ready, Chassagne, which was my fav of the flight showed the power with nice lemon and minerality while Meursault was creamy.
Second flight was rather interesting and we were divided. I liked the brightness of Jadot with aromas of wild raspberry and elegance. I think this one is closing down and should be revisited in 10 years. Rhys on the nose had dark raspberry concentrate and incredible balance, Keith went crazy for it and guessing it was Chambolle. I loved the Rhys and consider tham to be the best Californian Pinot and kudos to Kevin for making wines with such a balance and harmony.
In third flight clear winner was Hosanna, which was such a beautiful and balanced wine. Castello di Ama was big and ripe and seamed little out of balance.
Fourth flight was very interesting and there was our unsuspected WOTN, Benziger Cab Reserve, which unfortunately is not made anymore. It was the last wine poured and we went wow. Margaux was very primary, loaded with ripe fruit, 3 tasters choose it as their #1 while 6 Choose Benziger
(in parentheses are how many first, second, third and so on places did wine get)
1st flight
2004 Jadot Puligny Montrachet Clos de la Garenne, DDM (4,4,2,0)
2004 Jadot Chassagne Montrachet La Romanée (6,3,0,1)
2004 Jadot Meursault Les Perrieres (0,2,7,1)
2004 Craggy Range Chardonnay, Les Beaux Cailloux (0,1,1,8)
2nd flight
2006 Jadot Griottes-Chambertin (5,3,1,1)
2006 Rhys Pinot Noir Swan Terrace (4,5,0,1)
2006 Chacra “32”, Patagonia (1,1,5,3)
2006 Chacra “55”, Patagonia (0,1,4,5)
3rd flight
2002 Craggy Range Merlot, Gimblett Gravels (0,7,2,0)
2001 Chateau Hosanna, Pomerol (8,0,0,2)
2000 Castello di Ama, Vigna l’Apparita Merlot (0,1,1,7)
1999 Benziger Merlot, Reserve (2,1,6,0)
4th flight
1996 Chateau Margaux (3,2,2,2,1)
1996 Sassicaia (0,1,5,0,4)
2000 Cos d’Estournel (0,2,3,3,2)
2000 Sassicaia (1,2,2,4,1)
1997 Benziger Cabernet Sauvignon, Reserve (6,3,0,1,0)