Best Ice Cream You Can Buy in a Store

[Steve_Gautier]

When you want to take a break from the search for the holy grail, Tilamook ice cream is very good and even Target carries it. A recently discovered ice cream for us, the mouthfeel and taste is extra creamy, and the flavor combos are yummy. I recommend their “Udderly Chocolate” served over a Ghirardelli brownie made with walnuts.

I’ve had Tilamook at the creamery in Oregon and it was awesome. When they recently came to my local supermarket I was excited but was not impressed. It has a unique mouthfeel but something just doesn’t seem right about it to me, and didn’t love the flavors we tried either. Not terrible, but not what I’d hoped for either.

Interesting you say this. I have felt that way about Jeni’s. Enjoyed it much better in their St. Louis retail store than the grocery store version.

[AdrianReyes]

Ice Cream Snickers

[Robert_Pollard-Smith]

Finished off a tub of Tillamook’s Tillamook Mudslide. Graeter’s it ain’t, but it is mighty good nonetheless.

[ryancurry]

McConnell’s Vanilla Bean. Great clean vanilla flavor. They control their milk supply. It’s the best.

[alan_weinberg]

Tried a lot, but always come back to Häagen-Dazs chocolate chocolate chip.

[marc_shivers]

I eat a lot of ice cream, and try new pints regularly. My current favorite by a good margin in Milk Bar Cornflake Chocolate Chip Marshmallow. Graeter’s and Jeni’s are in back-up rotation.

[Robert_Pollard-Smith]

McConnell’s Vanilla Bean. Great clean vanilla flavor. They control their milk supply. It’s the best.

Ryan, have you tried Graeter’s Madagascar Vanilla Bean?