Best Ice Cream You Can Buy in a Store

[Henry_Kiichli]

UDF…!

We used to call it you dumb fuckers

[Rick_Bollig]

Every time I try a new brand at WholeFoods or Gelson’s or any of the fancier stores, I always think Häagen-Dazs has them beat. I always come back to them.

I like both vanilla and strawberry from HD.

[Brent_C_l_a_y_t_o_n]

I buy VanLeeuwen Ice cream in their stores. Is this a trick question?

[Venkat_K]

I was going to say Talenti, but then I read some of the comments above. Haven’t had Talenti in a while. So sad. I kinda wish they had a premium vanilla product or something and passed on the cost…

But, I’ll put in my vote for Coolhaus Tahitian Vanilla Bean “Sammie” (ice cream sandwich). Some of the best quality vanilla ice cream I’ve ever tasted. Though to be fair, I have not had this in a long time either.

[Jim_Stewart]

When you want to take a break from the search for the holy grail, Tilamook ice cream is very good and even Target carries it. A recently discovered ice cream for us, the mouthfeel and taste is extra creamy, and the flavor combos are yummy. I recommend their “Udderly Chocolate” served over a Ghirardelli brownie made with walnuts.

[Robert_Pollard-Smith]

APB from Graeter’s re new flavor, Midnight Snack—

“Your mystery flavor has been revealed! Inspired by late-night cravings, we’ve added crunchy chocolate-covered pretzels, sweet and salty peanut butter cups, and fudgy brownie pieces to a rich and tasty malt ice cream.”

[RyanC]

Van Leeuwen’s Cookie’s & Cream – currently in my freezer – is super delicious. Perhaps not as good their honeycomb, but not far off.

[Rick_Allen]

When you want to take a break from the search for the holy grail, Tillamook ice cream is very good and even Target carries it. A recently discovered ice cream for us, the mouthfeel and taste is extra creamy, and the flavor combos are yummy. I recommend their “Udderly Chocolate” served over a Ghirardelli brownie made with walnuts.

I don’t know if you get Tillamook’s Tillamook Mudslide back east, but it is an overdose of chocolate.

[Robert_M_yers]

I buy VanLeeuwen Ice cream in their stores. Is this a trick question?

They actually just started carrying this at our local market. Do they do anything special to look for?

[RichardFlack]

Well, Kraft Mac and Cheese Ice Cream Exists Now

Thought you were joking. Seems you may not be joking. I’m both scared and oddly intrigued…

Any stranger than

FRom the Magician of Bray , one of his early signature dishes.

[Brent_C_l_a_y_t_o_n]

The mac and cheese is amazeballs

[Jim_Stewart]

When you want to take a break from the search for the holy grail, Tillamook ice cream is very good and even Target carries it. A recently discovered ice cream for us, the mouthfeel and taste is extra creamy, and the flavor combos are yummy. I recommend their “Udderly Chocolate” served over a Ghirardelli brownie made with walnuts.

I don’t know if you get Tillamook’s Tillamook Mudslide back east, but it is an overdose of chocolate.

We had this tonight for the first time, Rick. Also over a brownie. Chocolate overdose indeed! (not that there’s anything wrong with that)

[RyanC]

Van Leeuwen is now offering pizza flavored ice cream: Van Leeuwen Launches Pizza-Flavored Ice Cream Nationwide at Walmart - Thrillist

I’d definitely try it

[Robert_M_yers]

We would all like a taste, because it seems impossible, But how is that company doing who sold Turkey dinner Soda? That’s just not a sustainable product line.

[Brent_C_l_a_y_t_o_n]

Mac & Cheese and Pizza flavors available nationally at Walmart-

Van Leeuwen Launches Seven Exclusive Flavors Nationwide

[J_Rock]

I haven’t had all of the different brands of ice cream, but Tillamook is awesome and it’s not even expensive. It’s my favorite.

[Linda_Baehr]

We would all like a taste, because it seems impossible, But how is that company doing who sold Turkey dinner Soda? That’s just not a sustainable product line.

They brought it back!

Jones' Turkey & Gravy Soda Is Coming Back After a Decade Away

[Mattstolz]

I cant believe more people haven’t mentioned Jeni’s. if you are a chocolate fan, the Darkest Chocolate is the single most chocolatey ice cream I have ever had. personally, my favorite is the Peanut butter with Chocolate Flecks (previously known as “Buckeye State”) or Bangkok Peanut (which might now have a new flavor but is essentially peanut butter ice cream with curry).

[Jay_Miller]

I cant believe more people haven’t mentioned Jeni’s. if you are a chocolate fan, the Darkest Chocolate is the single most chocolatey ice cream I have ever had. personally, my favorite is the Peanut butter with Chocolate Flecks (previously known as “Buckeye State”) or Bangkok Peanut (which might now have a new flavor but is essentially peanut butter ice cream with curry).

My experiences with Jeni are all over the place. I don’t care for most of them but love some. I agree that the chocolate is fantasic.

[Michae1_P0wers]

When you want to take a break from the search for the holy grail, Tilamook ice cream is very good and even Target carries it. A recently discovered ice cream for us, the mouthfeel and taste is extra creamy, and the flavor combos are yummy. I recommend their “Udderly Chocolate” served over a Ghirardelli brownie made with walnuts.

I’ve had Tilamook at the creamery in Oregon and it was awesome. When they recently came to my local supermarket I was excited but was not impressed. It has a unique mouthfeel but something just doesn’t seem right about it to me, and didn’t love the flavors we tried either. Not terrible, but not what I’d hoped for either.