In this market, you ain’t gonna find an “Epiphany” at $200, except MAYBE with a recently-released champagne [but note below here that the 1996 champagnes are already heading into the stratosphere].
GET A WINE-SEARCHER PRO PRESCRIPTION BEFORE YOU START PURCHASING.
My jaw dropped when I started looking at just the “lesser” Grand Crus, like Clos de la Roche and Clos Vougeot. It simply ain’t happening anywhere within a country mile of $200.
Here are some wines which appear to be available [i.e. physically present and actually on the market], right now in the United States, from what serious wine-snobs would consider to be rather down-market labels [meaning no Screagle, no 1st Growths, no DRC/Roumier/Mugnier/Rousseau, no Ramonet, no Keller, etc etc etc], but which I am confident would deliver for me:
PS: If you were in Europe, then you could find some Rieslings & Gruners from Hirtzberger & FX Pichler, with some bottle age on them, but free Wine-Searcher isn’t showing any aged Austrian wine for sale in the USA right now.
.
Still needs some work on Barolo. Your 2011 Rinaldi Tre Tine should be pretty good as an example of a young but drinkable Barolo. But your 2008 Conterno … too young. I wouldn’t touch that. Benchmark has some Giacosa Barbarescos - e.g. the 2004 or 2001 Santo Stefano- which would be better choices. Yes they aren’t Barolo but they will be excellent exemplars of how good Nebbiolo can be. Or hunt around for white label Giacosa Falletto Barolo from 1997, 1998, 1999, 2000, 2001, or 2004. Or splurge on a red label if you find one in your price range (admittedly a challenge). But these white labels are magnificent.
I would add the 2005 Geantet-Pansiot Charmes Chambertin Grand Cru, available for $215 and $225 if you search Winesearcher. Have not had that wine but have had the 2005 Geantet-Pansiot village wines and they are superb, that wine should be fantastic.