I chuckled at that too… and that’s the crux of the issue for me. Great story. Passion. The art of winemaking. A true character, an iconoclast. Doing it his own way. Then I tasted the wines and the rest of it lost a lot of credence.
I think John understands that, Evan.
But at first glance the two statements do look odd snuggling up so close to each other.
[Which, of course, was the intended effect.]
With me it wasn’t a matter of losing credence (not sure really what that means).
Over time I simply came, grudgingly, to the realization that (generally speaking) he’s not interested in making the kinds of wines I like to buy, cellar, and drink. It doesn’t seem to me that this is through ignorance or laziness on his part… he’s simply looking off in a different direction.
Bruce, I guess I mean that I lost a little belief in the goal, and a little interest as well. With all the background and romanticized notions, and the results being so grossly undrinkable, what does it matter how hard he’s trying and what his motivation is?
It’s like someone who’s utterly tone deaf and rhythmically impaired but a huge fan and scholar of music pouring their heart and effort into a debut album. You can care a lot and have very good reasons and a very good story and still make a terrible album.
I imagine we’re pretty much in agreement here, though we probably express ourselves slightly differently.
If the goal is “being as non-manipulative as possible” I still believe in it fervently. One of the immediate benefits of Cornelissen’s project for me is that it demonstrates clearly the consequences of going that far down the road. People who taste his wines and like them would possibly want to try going even further with some of the practices he employs. I look at him and see the need to walk things back a bit.
As to losing interest… I don’t buy his wines to cellar any more. I do buy them periodically to taste with friends. I’d love to be more supportive of his work out of a general sense of “alignment” with much of what he does [and I’ve never been a fan of the “It’s what’s in the glass that counts” club] , but can’t really rationalize it.
I’d still characterize myself as being interested in what he’s doing, though.
I try to limit the time spent in passing judgement on other winemakers. But when I’m inclined to do so, I look at how well they communicate their goals to others, and how closely they come to achieving those goals.
Whether or not they make wine I like is incidental to the matter.
I’m not trying to criticize the winemakers intent. It’s just that there are winemakers, like Jeff and Josh, that are making wines in a fashion that is “hands off” and non- malipulative, yet are very pure expressions of their varietal, vineyard, and terroir(insert ball washing emoticon). That to me, is talent. JMO, of course.
Hank,
Different wines contain different levels of Cinnamic acids- the main group of precursors of the aroma compounds Brett produces. Some wines are high in these, others not. It may just be that the wine that always gets Bretty are high in these and so is more likely to produce aroma compounds if exposed to Brett.
When I was in school my research was on Brett, and I inoculated several wines with each of our 30 strains. Sometimes a particular strain would produce vastly different aromas in different wines. Some wines would produce very little or no noticeable aromas, even though the Brett cells were alive and viable in the wine. This could be the case with a subsequent wine you put in the previously Bretty barrels. And how were the barrels sanitized? There are a lot of variables possible.
that’s about as good of an explanation that I have heard. At any rate, its not a real problem for me as it seems contained, I know to expect it and I can use it as a blending tool. Plus, it keeps my filtering chops in good shape.
Any brett I do not have to worry about is ok by me !
I dont know…I had this Cab called Pretty Sally from Garagiste that made me upchuck. No wine had ever done that before. I have a tought stomach but this thing was foul.
Not for drinking, no.
Periodically to use in tastings to demonstrate certain ideas, yes. And I’ll probably buy the odd bottle every now and again just to see how things are progressing… it may very well be that he eventually works into a place where I’m more comfortable.
But the amount of money that I would devote to purchasing his wines is way down from what it used to be.
I’ve had exactly the same experience.
For the first 3 years I worked an old syrah vineyard, I did get bretts in the wine from these grapes and from these grapes only. It was not transferable by any mean (barrels, hoses…).
It decreased progressively as I stopped using herbicides and went for either plowing under the row or even better by seeding white clover along with vine garlic (Allium vineale)and leak (Allium polyanthum), 2 highly mycchoriza dependent plants…
My take is that brett in the vineyard could be the result of unbalanced bacterias and mold populations in the top soil (???).
I was able to stop using any sulfur at winemaking for that vineyard which was absolutely not possible before.
Hi Eric - That’s an interesting idea you put forth regarding vineyard managment. BTW-It’s great to see you on this board. I very much enjoyed meeting you at the Dressner tasting last year in Los Angeles. Keep up the great work!