Who are your favorite producers of Mosel Kabinett from recent vintages?

In the latest issue of Mosel Fine Wines, Jean Fisch and David Rayer highlight, in this order, five producers of 2022 Kabinett wines: Falkenstein, Dr. Hermann (Kabinett of the vintage), Maximin Grünhaus, Egon Müller, and Willi Schaefer. They say that the finest Kabinetts from these producers “all share this sense of precision, balance, and subtle zest usually only found in cooler vintages.” I’m curious who will be their top picks for the 2023 vintage, which they explain is “a tad riper and richer” and “less homogenous” than the last three.

2 Likes

Love Falkenstein, WS& Muller. And of course Keller. 2021 Abts Kabi is amazing

2 Likes

Julian Haart’s 2022 wines were not reviewed….

Why weren’t they?

Thanks. I haven’t tasted the 2021 Abtsberg Kabinett.

They only exist in legends.

1 Like

Stuart Pigott, who only reviews for James Suckling the same group of Mosel producers each year, gave Julian Haart’s 2022 Ohligsberg Kabinett (white label) 100 points, for the third time in a row.

1 Like

The Ohligsberg 1925 magnum must get 105 then!

2 Likes

Yes, the 1925 Ohligsberg from Freiherr von Schorlemer.

I was surprised they highlighted the Dr. Hermann Erdener Treppchen Riesling Kabinett Alte Reben as the Kabinett of the vintage. I was really impressed with their Pinot. Has there been any recents changes on the winemaking team?

There are lots of other Kabinetts I like that are not on your list, the #1 from a personal favorite standpoint is Ludes.

2 Likes

I haven’t had that Kabinett and don’t know if the winemaking has changed at Dr. Hermann.

By the way, that’s not my list.

My favorite 5 kabinetts in recent vintages (2020 and later – excluding feinherbs and trockens)

  1. '21 Falkenstein Gisela
  2. '21 W. Schaefer GH Kabi (showed better than GD for some reason)
  3. '21 Vollenweider Wolfer Goldgrube Kabi
  4. '20 AJ Adams Dhroner Hofberg Kabi
  5. (three-way tie) '20 Weiser Kunstler Wolfer Sonnenlay Kabi/ '21 Von Schubert Abtsberg Kabi / '21 Richter GH Kabi

However, I was really loving the '22 Falkenstein Onkel Peter last night. Lean and focused with just a hint of sweetness accented with grapefruit and citrus oil – really opened up over the course of the evening while eating Chinese dumplings. Really delicious and electric – I actually liked this better than the '22 Gisela or the '21 Onkel Peter Spatlese Feinherb.

5 Likes

Thanks for your top five Kabinetts since 2020. Gisela is special, no matter the vintage. I really like Willi Schaefer’s 2021s, especially the auction Kabinett from Domprobst.

There’s a reason why Mosel Fine Wines rated Onkel Peter tops in the 2022 lineup from Falkenstein.

My favorites from 2023 at Falkenstein are Gisela and Mia.

3 Likes

Not a bad list. My favourite 5 Kabinetts since the 21 vintage have been:

  1. Julian Haart, Ohligsberg Alte Reben 2021
  2. Untelrind, Brauneberger Juffer Sonnenuhr 2021
  3. Keller, Schubertslay Alte Reben 2021
  4. Max Kilburg, Ohligsberg 2021
  5. Hofgut Falkenstein, Gisela 2021

All 21s… though there are some excellent 22s and very good 23s as well (though my tasting of 23s has been limited so far, Julian Haart’s Goldtropfchen in particular has a lot of potential). My top producers would be the same list, wirh Egon Muller not featuring only because I haven’t tasted as much as I used to.

2 Likes

Thanks for your top-five list. I also like the 2021 vintage.

Ohligsberg is an impressive site, as is Geierslay, formerly known as Neuberg, farther up the Rondelbach. The soil is slate mixed with quartz. I haven’t tasted the last few vintages from Egon Müller. It’s a shame. I’m curious to taste the lighter-style Kabinetts from 2021 and 2022. As I understand it, the must weights, measured in degrees Oechsle, were in the low instead of high 80s.

2 Likes

This is the thread I needed. Found 6 Falkenstein Gisela 2022 at Thatchet

2 Likes

I’m glad you could find six bottles of 2022 Gisela at Thatcher’s Wine.

I like that Mosel Fine Wines noted that they included only those wines on their list of highlights that are still mostly in the style of “Kabinett.”

Upon further review, there are at least a couple of Kabinetts on their list of highlights that are not Kabinett-like. They even say so in their tasting note for one of them.

The comments seem to dovetail well with a quick analysis. (2019-2023)

Hofgut Falkenstein / Avg. 92.0 pts
Joh. Jos. Prüm / Avg. 91.9
Weingut Max Ferd. Richter / Avg. 91.0 pts
Julian Haart / Avg. 91.9 pts
Dr. Loosen / Avg. 89.3 pts
Willi Schaefer / Avg. 92.0 pts
Peter Lauer / Avg. 92.0 pts
Dr. Hermann / Avg. 91.5 pts
Weingut Günther Steinmetz / Avg. 90.4 pts
Weingut Hermann Ludes / Avg. 92.1 pts

I don’t really like this because a substantial number of people who evaluate wines on CellarTracker don’t rate them or use Like/Don’t Like. So I was playing around using sentiment analysis to see if I could get more interesting results. I haven’t got it correct yet, but it yielded a list of top wines that has some interesting divergence from the top producers and makes me believe that Von Schubert should be in that list.

Here are the results based on the sentiment analysis of the tasting notes, scores, likes/dislikes of Kabinett wines from the Mosel region:

  1. Von Schubert Maximin Grünhäuser Herrenberg
  2. Weingut Hermann Ludes Thörnicher (see below)
  3. Carl Loewen Longuicher Maximin Herrenberg
  4. Julian Haart Piesporter Grafenberg
  5. Karp-Schreiber Brauneberger Juffer
  6. Schloss Lieser Juffer
  7. Weingut Günther Steinmetz Neumagener Rosengärtchen
  8. Willi Schaefer Graacher Domprobst
  9. Von Schubert Maximin Grünhäuser Abtsberg
  10. Von Schubert Maximin Grünhäuser Bruderberg

I won’t bore y’all with the technical details, but I have mixed confidence in this list. Mostly I am still experimenting and learning. I also didn’t cross check this list at all. But the signal was pretty strong on the sentiment analysis scale.

Note - this Ludes is an example of where I suspect the analysis is going off - I think this is an aggregate of 3 wines and ChatGPT isn’t picking this up correctly, likely because my input list has format issues (it was 1000+ wines.) I think I can refine this and make it work better down the road.

4 Likes

Thanks for your analysis.