2008 was one of the most underrated vintages ever in CdP. For the first ten years or so, one could say they showed well young, but bigger years would outpace them. They are 18 now and domaine by domaine almost always more pleasurable to drink than the 07. Next on the underrated list are the 11s and the 21s. Caution, I base these evaluations on a handful of non-Cambie wines I drink regularly. YMMV
I have not enjoyed the ‘09s.
For the big run of vintages in the early 2000’s, I always preferred ‘04 and ‘06 to much hyped ‘05 and ‘07
I’ve only had 2 other vintages prior to the 1998 Vieux Telegraphe and iirc all post-1998 until vintage 2005. While I’m generally impressed with the wines, it’s alway the 1998 that is the most memorable and has become my gold standard.
Good to read about the positive tasting results and added comments on the 2008. It’ll be on my radar from now on.
Inaugural post on WB!
We enjoyed this CdP last night. For those that are not aware, this is a Chateauneuf that flies somewhat under the radar. Relatively small production from a domaine (La Bastide Saint Dominique) that does not get a lot of attention.
This bottling (Secrets De Pignan; 100% Grenache from a three acre vineyard adjacent to Rayas planted in 1920) shows considerable variation from vintage to vintage but can be relied upon to deliver a gorgeous perfumed aroma and explosive, silky Grenache fruit. The 2020 version is a bit disjointed and hot relative to other vintages, but lovely nonetheless. If you have an itch for 100% pure, luscious Southern Rhone Grenache, this is a bottling to try to get your hands on.
The Domaine offers a number of additional bottlings that are worthy of attention as well, including Les Hesperides (50% Grenache and 50% Mourvedre).
Those are indeed great but not easy to find. I had the 2007 a little while ago
This 2006 was the fifth of six purchased back in the day. Earlier bottles were just broad and plummy, with no delimitation. It’s finally come around. The 2009 reminds me of 2006. I’ll try again around 2030.
Yeah, didn’t bother opening the 05 or 07. I think 2005 still needs time. 2030??? God I hope 2007 comes around sometime, but I suspect it will always be the indifferent warm wine it always has been. I’d be thrilled if a non-gourmet pizzeria offered it at $8-$10 BTG. But not a worthy vin de garde.
I offloaded most of my 2005 wines years ago, but still have a small handful. I really loved the 2004 VT. My last bottle remaining from the ones I purchased on release was corked, however.
Also in white, including a rare Clairette rose
2004! As of last year mine are all gone. Wish I had purchased more.
My first time with Dard et Ribo and really enjoyed it. I think the 2024 vintage is likely to be strong for this producer.
- 2024 Dard et Ribo Saint-Joseph - France, Rhône, Northern Rhône, Saint-Joseph (7/28/2026)
Extremely purple color. Very funky on PnP, but blows off quickly. Decanted for an hour.
Aromas that leap from the glass. Violets, ripe raspberries, thyme, sliced olives and smoked meat. A big blast of iron and a granitic, stemmy tension that immediately recalls Gonon. Medium, fine tannins. Terrific energy in the glass with a great spine of acidity. A very expressive, lifted Syrah and it’s impossible to put this bottle down once opened. Exceptional.
This would be great with seared, bloody-rare meat and earthy French green lentils.
I’ve only had D&R once and it was similarly awesome.
Are these mostly sold to the restaurant trade? I’ve never really seen them anywhere other than auction sites.
They’re in a number of the natural and natural-leaning wine stores here in NYC.
Over two nights, I inhaled a 2018 Delas ‘Les Launes’ rouge [Crozes Hermitage] with more delight than I had expected. I’ve had their ‘Grand Chemins’ Crozes bottling over the years in several good solar vintages, and always been underwhelmed, so I wasn’t expecting much from this. [Chemins is a single vineyard contract - but now domaine plot - from the Chassis plains; Les Launes is an AOC wide negociant blend] But this time the lower level, more direct wine was quite good, perhaps a function of consuming at age 8. I would also note that it’s richer, almost New World, in it’s fruitiness. This would be a good gateway to the Northern Rhone for those interested in expanding their tastes beyond California Rhone Rangers. 14% abv, big monochrome fruit, mostly resolved tannin, light structure and low acid. Production is high; there are 20k cases of this. JLL writes that it’s typically destemmed, subject to punchdowns, and composed mostly of purchased fruit with a little bought in wine too. The oak is modest - 40% of 2-3 year barrels - with the rest of the wine raised in vats. Natural closure. Imported by Maison, Marques and Domaine. Sediment is very light for the age. I was quite pleased with this and would assign it a B+, although I suppose finishing a bottle over two evenings rather than three is the real measure of my affection.
I charred some Brussels in the iron skillet, tossing them with preserved radish and crystallized ginger, dressed with a yuzu sauce.
Norwegian steelhead, glazed with a sticky eel sauce. Cat #2 goes crazy for this and hops up in the dining table (!) trying to self serve. I pan fried a small piece of the belly trimmings (plain, no sauce) in butter for him, since he can’t have seasonings.
PS: I have no idea why, but Learmonth’s 2005 book on the Northern Rhone does not discuss the ‘Grand Chemins’ Crozes bottling at all despite it being in some form of production since the 90’s albeit with subtle name changes. The much less seen smaller production Crozes that Delas makes were all covered.
2005 Jean-Michel Stephan Côte-Rôtie Vieille Vigne en Coteaux
Loved this in 2023 - will try again this year: From CT
I brought this from DK, a wee bit nervous - could it stand the trip? Oh, yes. Maybe the best wine of this years Tour de France, this is vertical, strict, stony, very much old vine Syrah. Olives, smoke, medicine-cabinet; unchanged on day 2. 97 points
#Bagnols-en-Fôret
uhhhh yes. he crushed it in 22 and 23, can drink some of those pretty directly. ![]()
i have i think…5 left of this…let me know how it is
We enjoyed this absolutely delicious bottle last night. With a still youthful pinot-esque light red rim and a dark center, the wine opens with a complex and enticing aroma of underbrush laced with red fruit, herbs and smoke that held steady throughout the evening. On the palate the wine is medium bodied, silky and luscious, bursting with layers of red fruit, mushrooms, and spices that linger seemingly for ages. An extremely well-balanced, multi-dimensional wine that is fully mature and yet has plenty of life ahead.
I have had this wine more than once annd greatly enjoy it. But, really, for me, Southern Rhônes are about as far from Pinot Noir as you can get without being maybe an Alsace Sylvaner or something. As a dyed in the wool Southern Rhône fan, who also loves a good Burgundy when it befalls him, I’ve never understood the impulse to compare them.




