Which Champagne are you drinking?

I am curious about this too. '67 Cristal is about the best Champagne or any wine I have had. I do love 2008 as a vintage but haven’t had 08 Cristal. The '96 Krug and Salon I have had don’t feel like they’re quite the distance runners initially projected although I haven’t had either for several years. Time will tell.

Curious as to when Champagne vineyards become a toxic wasteland. We’ve all seen the pictures of trash poking out of the ground and heard reports of mass spraying of synthetics but I don’t think that was always the case and also imagine some of the bigger, better houses weren’t exactly nuking their livelihoods. I believe there has been a shift to more ecological farming and that’s a good thing in multiple ways.

I think we’ll just have to see. Cristal is made totally differently now; it’s now always made from grapes from the same 42 sites, which are farmed organically and biodynamically, where it used to be selected from any state vineyards based on taste. There are also obviously changes from climate change. Dosage has also reduced over time due to higher physiologic maturity. I personally think champagne has improved dramatically in quality over time, mostly due to improved farming practices and the grower movement.

1 Like

1996 salon is starting to drink well now but will also be drinking well 30 years from now. I think 96 Krug (and definitely 96 CDM) will also age nicely. There are several batches of 96 Krug, so there’s some variability.

1 Like

I totally agree overwll quality is much higher, as is baseline. I am a big fan of many changes. I just think we’ve also lost some aspects and dumbed down others, though perhaps more in a few other regions, white burgundy being the most obvious to me, and maybe Bordeaux, though I have less recent experience.

1 Like

I definitely like both although I sold my remaining 96 Salon based on the $$ I could get vs how much I liked them. Saved my Krugs. Drinking 95s which are plenty good while the 96s rest.

This evening in the cheap seats a bottle of Waris-Larmandier GC Particules Crayeuses Extra Brut. I wish I had noticed @scottkieser 's note previously, because for most of this bottle I also found it rather too crisp/tart and uni-dimensional for my palate. But after it had been open for an hour and warmed somewhat it fleshed out considerably. If I had more of these I think I’d decant them.

My full CT TN

3 Likes

1000 bottles and you don’t drink much or like it old?

:wink:

1 Like

Yep. I have entirely too much wine for how much I drink, but that’s ok.

I guess we’ll just have to see.

In Bdx it seems unlikely we’ll have a run like the 90s with so many bad vintages, but will the highs be as high? Some people with more experience than me say some of the newer wines made (for example 16) are as good as the best wines of the past, idk though.

In burgundy warmer temperatures have obviated the need for chapitilization (or blending with non-burgundy wine) in many cases. I have to assume that the sugar coming from
the grapes is better than exogenously adding it, but idk.

In champagne I think the overall quality of farming is better and the vineyards and cellars are cleaner. I think personally that translates to better wine, but there are some negative effects that could play some role like climate change, microplastics, etc. I guess we’ll just have to see how it plays out at the grande marques.

2 Likes

The negative changes I am talking about are not just hard factors like microplastics or climate issues. I am pointing to deliberate choices to make wine that is of a certain style, particularly wine that is immediately accessible, though that isn’t the only element. I view many of those chiices as unfortunate, and mourn that we may never (or at least rarely) get to see great aged wines like we used to in some regions. For those who don’t care for truly mature champagne or white burgundy, dor instance, that may not be such a tragedy.

3 Likes

I guess I’m not really seeing that with the grand marques and I don’t think it was ever the way it was; there’s always been vintages to cellar and vintages to drink earlier; per the discussion on the other thread Brad thinks that’s why, for example the 15 Cristal was made. 96 salon is 28 years old and isn’t ready. I’m sure 08 Cristal will be the same, we decanted the last bottle we opened 3h.

I would be happy if those wines were drinking well in 2028-2032.

1 Like

J. Lassalle Special Club 2012:

A flashy wine - full-bodied and rich with vivid strawberry notes which burst on the palate like Pop Rocks and complements the creamy Ricotta cheese like flavor and texture. The upfront richness gives way to tart lemon, orange and green apple notes, carried by aggresive acidity which propels a long finish. It’s dramatic and intense, but is missing a little depth for my tastes. There is no disgorgement date on the bottle; I believe this to be a fairly recent disgorgment. I suspect this will age brilliantly - there is a noticeable autolytic character in the background which should fill out nicely with mire age. Very good, but not exciting, at least not yet.

7 Likes

I have some ‘13 J.Ls. I was just contemplating opening one last weekend. I will resist the urge for a bit longer :stuck_out_tongue_closed_eyes:

1 Like

I don’t regret opening, for what it’s worth. I just think there is plenty of upside.

1 Like

  • 2012 Pehu Simonet Champagne Grand Cru Fins Lieux No 3 Mailly Millésimé - France, Champagne, Champagne Grand Cru (7/6/2024)
    100% PN, mostly from les Poules in Mailly. Vinification in barriques. Disg. 1/2021, dosage 2g/L.
    Medium fleeting mousse. Small sluggish bead. Color is light gold with a hint of salmon. Not much on the nose - it comes across as watered down tincture and lightly sherried. On the palate, browning apple peel, browning nectarine, lemon. Mid palate has some stemmy bitterness, almond skin and raspberry. Finish of toasted almond. Quite a lot of acidity, but the fruit doesn't seem to be still there to support it.
  • Additional note: I prefer the Face Nord series from Pehu-Simonet, which are also better priced. Maybe I waited too long to open this or there was something not quite right with my bottle.

  • NV Drappier Champagne Cuvée Charles de Gaulle - France, Champagne (7/6/2024)
    80%PN, 20% Chard from Urville. Full malo, partially aged in wood, unfiltered, low sulfur. Aged 36 months in bottle. Dosage 6.5 g/L
    Med-light yellow color. Medium mousse. Med-small bead. The dosage comes across on the front-end; apricot, lemon, ginger a bit of toasted brioche. On the mid-palate, the acidity overtakes the dosage and comes through strongly, accompanied by grapefruit/pomelo zest. Med Long finish. Drappier recommends serving on the cooler side (47° F/ 8°C), which works well. At warmer temps, this champagne felt sluggish (maybe even cloying) and lost vibrancy.
  • Additional note: I am ambivalent about the dosage/acidity flip flop, but the husband liked this.
    5 Likes

    Vilmart on a rooftop in Venice does not suck

    23 Likes

    Crushing it, ladies and gents! I’m enjoying everyone’s notes so very much on my holiday weekend. :cheers:

    9 Likes

    How was it?

    It could suck if it gets any closer to the edge.