Extracted from a thread posted yesterday re 17 wines:
2014 LOUIS ROEDERER CRISTAL- I served this blind to the others, one of whom called it a 1990 and a few others had it as from the mid 1990s; this was my 2nd bottle, the first coming a few weeks ago when I was in NW Arkansas and bought it to share with dear friends; that first bottle was laden with tasty, rich lemon oil and good enough for me to buy some; this bottle was initially very different from the first one as it started out with some bitter and sour stone fruit notes with a hint of licorice; once tasted, the stone fruit was more specifically peach and tangerine, but still had some off-putting sour and bitterness; after 20+ minutes, the lemon showed up and took over and we’re back to the rich lemon oil profile enhanced by a creamy texture.
With 5 other champagnes being poured and a limited number of wine glasses, few, if any had a chance to experience its true expression at this early stage. It certainly needs a few more years to develop and mature and shed some of its unpleasant notes.
2007 ALFRED GRATIEN BRUT MILLESIME- oak influence was evidenced throughout as this gave up accents of pepper, hazelnut, toasty, vanilla, brioche, laden citrus, yellow apple and strawberry notes; the more dominate licorice and pepper notes were mindful of Piper Heidsieck Rare; it’s a nice bubbly for those who enjoy the above notes of which I am one.
2008 CHAMPAGNE CHARLIER & FILS SPECIAL CLUB- bottled 4/09, disgorged 11/15/22 with a dose of 3.4 gpl; therefore, an extra brut; 70% Chardonnay, 15% Pinot Noir and 15% Pinot Meunier; it was big and yeasty with some nutty sour lemon and yellow apple notes while being full bodied with a soft and smooth mousse; I liked it although it finished with some musty, dusty notes that I could have done without. Perhaps more air would have benefitted this bottle.
NV KRUG GRAND CUVEE- this bottle was at least 4-5 years old and my photo did not capture the code clearly enough to research it {this was before the ID Code/ app was implemented}, but some of us were guessing it to be the 168 edition or perhaps 166 eme; my best guess is this was the 166 which was based with 2010, but strengthened by a healthy addition of 2000 to bolster the 39% Chardonnay and more Meunier, in this case 16% of the total; following its medium yellow color came toasty brioche accented lemon, lime, grapefruit and apple notes were delivered in a mellow textured medium while sporting a backbone of bright acidity.
2002 CHAMPAGNE BOLLINGER GRAND ANNEE BRUT- 60% Pinot Noir and 40% Chardonnay, 71% from Grand Cru villages, 29% from Premier Crus; disgorged 2/11; yellow gold color; I expected this to be big and oxidative, if not more advanced and it was neither; certainly it was rich and full bodied, but nicely balanced while sporting some nice honey coated yellow apple with an unexpected accent of coconut and providing more elegance and finesse than power and thrust. I’d loved to have had more time with this to see where it would land after an hour or so.
2012 LOUIS ROEDERDER BRUT-70% Pinot Noir, 30% Chardonnay; dosed at 9 gpl; I’ve had a few lovely bottles of this release, but it’s been over a year or so and this bottle seemed very atypical in that it expressed spice, licorice and pepper accented apple and red cherry notes that reminded me of Piper Heidsieck Rare.
Cheers,
Blake