What makes a wine taste expensive?

I recently heard someone describe a wine as smelling expensive (“like the inside of a Bentley” was the quote). This made me wonder what qualities people think makes a wine smell or taste “expensive”?

Are there examples of relatively affordable bottles that may not have incredible complexity or nuance, but still have qualities that make them taste much more expensive than they are?

Wow… either one of the funniest or saddest description I’ve seen.

Leather and wood?

2 Likes

April 1 was like 63 days ago. Lol

Like when a wine doesn’t just have notes of chocolate, it has notes of valrhona chocolate.

5 Likes

has that “new wine smell”

1 Like

I have tasted many high caliber wines that had faint smell of piss. [pwn.gif]

Waiting for someone to get Chris Maybach to chime in…

You’d think a car like a Bentley would have great suspension and shocks - no way should you be spilling wine in one.

Glycerol, oak, alcohol. Mix.

“Like the inside of a Eurocopter Hermès EC 135 on the flight back from Screaming Eagle …”

3 Likes

I’ll take a non-joking shot at this question:

  • Glass to room filling aromas
  • Concentration
  • Layering (attack/midpalate/finish + integral structure)
  • Balance

Within that rubric, there can be deeply extracted and explosively dark fruit driven wine, or elegant and effusively earth-driven wines. So from my standpoint it’s more about the structural and textural aspects, not necessarily the exact aromas.

I’ve never been inside of a Bentley, but I’d wager a Bentley smells of expensive things like new leather and fine, polished wood finishes. A wine that is open and smells of new leather and fine, polished wood finishes would definitely have an expensive sheen to it.

1 Like

200% new oak.

1 Like

I remember describing a 2005 Trollat St Joseph as smelling like an expensive perfume counter at a department store, and I think your rubric is pretty good. I especially like that it doesn’t try to be literal about the actual smell of a Bentley

It’s in vogue for luxury cars to have “open pore” matte wood finishes - to prove that the wood isn’t plastic - as opposed to polished wood, and I wonder if that smells quite the same…

Grassl (in a good way)

3 Likes

Black forest cake hitsfan

1 Like

If it wasn’t obvious, the Bentley reference was meant to be a metaphor. I think the point was you open the door to a Bentley and you can tell by the look, feel, and even the smell of the new high quality leather that it’s an expensive car. The point was that just by smelling the wine you could tell it was an expensive bottle.

This. Stems do make a huge different in the aromatic perception of a wine, which is a big part of wine. Discovering the Grassl Liberte, Mineralite and Cru stems have drastically changed how much I get from wines I drink. I now often feel like I’m missing something in a wine when drinking wine from other stems. At times it feels like I’m not able to coax all of the wine has to offer with other stems. Personal preferences for stems vary widely, but I’d argue that finding one that works for you can elevate your drinking experience drastically.

2 Likes

You should stop being a dickhead to the sommelier when ordering items off a list. And make sure you see him open the bottle…

The label? newhere

1 Like