What is your favorite Carlisle Zinfandel bottling/vineyard

I am reorganizing and indexing my cellar. My Carlisle collection is ridiculous, but that’s OK because we really like Carlisle Zinfandel. I am frequently asked by “civilians” how much wine I have and I respond, “A lot.” When they then ask, “How many is a lot?” I respond, “what is your definition of a lot?” My next comment is usually, “Oh, I have that many bottles of Carlisle Zinfandel.”

The source of the problem is that Mike Officer has more Zinfandel bottlings than Todd allows poll choices, so if you are in the “other” category, specify bellow.

I do not have all of these, but I do have 18 different bottlings, and that does not include the Bedrock Carlisle Vineyard bottling. So which one do you like the most? QPR does not count because the Sonoma County bottling wins that hands down.

PS - I hate it when some 12 year old changes the coding so I have to relearn something.

  • Papera
  • Carlisle
  • Montafi (fka Tom Feeney)
  • Dry Creek Valley
  • Sonoma County
  • Bedrock
  • Pagani
  • Mancini
  • Monte Rosso
  • Kirschenman
  • Limerick Lane
  • Fanucchi Wood Road
  • Lingenfelder
  • Sonoma valley
  • Russian River Valley
  • Carlo’s
  • Pietro’s
  • Old Vines
  • Piner Olivet
  • Rossi
0 voters
3 Likes

Carlisle makes amazing Zins (my favorite producer) and I’m starting to collect plenty of their aged bottles.

Can’t wait to try more of these aged bottles in the next couple of years.

1 Like

Even though I don’t buy or consume as much zin as I used to, Carlisle is still the producer that represents the highest percentage of my cellar. For me Montafi is my favorite - but not by much. So many great vineyards they work with.

2 Likes

Carlisle is my favorite

1 Like

Some years ago, a group of 13 tasted verticals (same vintages) of the Montafi, Papera, and Carlisle Vineyards. At the end, when asked to name a favorite, there were four votes for each. The 13th attendee, Mr. Officer, broke the tie for his namesake vineyard.

2 Likes

I went with Montafi but could have also picked the Carlisle vyd. The former I love for its depth, richness, and layers. The latter has provided some of the most intense yet transparent and elegant manifestations of zinberry fruit. Both amazing world class sites.

2 Likes

Love RRV blend.

So hard to pick favorites, but I’ve gotta go Montafi #1, Papera #2, and Carlisle Vineyard a close #3 :cheers:

1 Like

Papera, Mancini, Carlisle

1 Like

My tasting note:

  • 2011 Carlisle Zinfandel Montafi Ranch - USA, California, Sonoma County, Russian River Valley (10/31/2020)
    This has now happened twice. I taste a wine blind that my wife selected. My comment, "this is a great Zin. My guess is not mountain fruit. The only Zin I have had that was this good in Carlisle Montafi Ranch." Nothing more needs be said. (94 points)

Posted from CellarTracker

2 Likes

Great question, hard to pick a favorite but if cornered it would go:

  1. Carlisle
  2. Montafi
  3. Piner-Olivet
  4. Monte Rosso
1 Like

It was Gum Tree Ranch.

2 Likes

Having had full bottles of both 2000 and 2001 Gum Tree at home I’d say that’s my vote as well.
From the vote of the 13 I voted Carlisle. It wasn’t the sexiest or sleekest, but to me the most complex of the three.

3 Likes

Ahhhh, such a good call! That would have been in my top three as well but i didnt even think of it (RIP Gum Tree).

Just finished the last bottle of 01 that i owned:

2001 Carlisle Gum Tree Ranch Zinfandel, Russian River Valley. Marciano cherries, and tart cranberry, and a beautiful and dominant note of eucalyptus. Probably my second favorite Carlisle of all time next to the 2007 Papera (man that wine was crazy good), so while I’m sad that this was my last bottle……I’m glad I’m going out on a high-note.

2 Likes

Wow, never even heard of Gum Tree!
My top three in order are:

  1. Papera
  2. Carlisle
  3. Montafi

My preference for Papera over Carlisle was narrowing so much last summer I tasted the 2019’s head to head & was surprised the Carlisle was my favorite. I might have to re-order my list if that trend continues!

2 Likes

Wasn’t gum tree ripped out to build condos or something like that, IIRC?

1 Like

Drank 01 Gum Tree out of mag a couple of times.

1 Like

“Alas, this is also our last vintage of Gum Tree as the vineyard has been sold for commercial real estate development. What a shame to lose such a historic Sonoma county treasure.”- Mike referring to 2001 vintage

3 Likes

My followup question is: what window are most of you drinking these wines at? I went very heavy in the 2012-14 years and notice some bottlings are singing and some seem old

I’ve been inspired by @Rich_Brown so I decided to purchase a good amount of aged Carlisle Zinfandel.

Will be picking them up tomorrow.

Interested to see if it was all worth it or not haha.

1 Like