I’m curious… What do you mean by their pricing methodology? All “top notch” Napa Cabs are pricey. Some much more then others. What makes these guys stand out in that realm?
I have a couple friends who are on the list, and seem to like them. I’ve only tasted a couple: a '95 Cabernet Grace Family Vineyard, made by Heidi Barrett, which had nice plush fruit, but with the oak still showing prominently after over a decade in the bottle; and the very chocolatey '04 Cru, which I rated 90+ pts.
I have had it a number of occasions and I own a bunch.
the Cru is NOT worth $50. I gave it a bad review a year ago on Cellartracker, I have since stopped scoring wines , but I gave it an 87 back then. I think it was just too young.
The 2005 V29 is excellent, and will age very gracefully in my opinion.
I have some Aida , but haven’t tried any of it yet.
I do think its pricey and for that reason , I passed on the current Aida offering. I am just hell bent on lowering my Cab purchases , especially in that price range. I did really enjoy it and its top notch, but damn you will pay for it and I have even found 05’s at BELOW RELEASE price out there at numerous locations.
I would say to me, the closest comparsion in taste is 2004 or 2005 Lokoya Mt. Veeder… very silky , smooth, long finish, you can tell this will age very well.
But for the price, I would probably buy a Maybach and Kobalt for about the price of 1 V29.