You guys gotta go easier on Jay. He lives in New York, so doesn’t really get to see much actual football. The Pro Bowl is relatively more noteworthy in New York that it is in most other places.
Isn’t the real problem here that Todd was taking a short cut in his sentence structure?
“Does anybody watch the Pro Bowl?” would be as obviously correct as “Does he watch the Pro Bowl?”
“He watches the Pro Bowl?” is a bit awkward and without the ? would imply a statement of fact but the formulation is not uncommon especially if spoken with a Jewish accent and a slightly disdainful inflection. While I’ve never heard heard or seen it used with anybody before this I am willing to accept it on those grounds.
Isn’t the real problem here that Todd was taking a short cut in his sentence structure?
Exactly. Todd’s subject (anybody, singular) and verb (watches, correct third person present perfect form) agree. It may sounds awkward depending on which missing words we assume.
“Does anybody watch” contains “watch” because the third person present tense ending modifies the auxiliary verb (does) rather than the main verb.
“Like, anybody watches the Pro Bowl” sounds perfectly fine.
As far as everybody, it’s also singular (pronouns ending in -one or -body are singular), as in “Everybody watches”.
So, the fault was not in Todd’s construction but in ourselves.
Don’t look at me. I don’t watch. We don’t watch. Camping World Stadium in Orlando. Not even interested in who shows up. A weekend off from football to anticipate the Big Game.