Sorry. The Gewurtz was the best white of the weekend including the Suey, Boots, Mr. K and a random 90 Yquem. For me, it actually topped most of the reds spare those I put in my Top Ten. BTW, The Boots topped the Suey for most in the crowd and the Yquem showed better than the Mr. K’s though those were not shabby by any means. More to follow.
Wow. Every time I think you guys have outdone yourself you up the game… What’s next, a vertical from large format? =)
E-Raised is one of my personal favorites as well. I have been impressed with the last few Imposter McCoys I’ve had, so sorry to see it didn’t show well.
i know the notes are voluminous, but would appreciate any info on the incognito drinking window. have a mag that’s getting cracked this weekend or next!
Incognito has been a real favorite of mine over the past 4-5 years. It took a couple of years in my opinion to unwind and show itself. Unfortunately, the bottle on Friday wasn’t showing all that well. It did not have the deep and rich core of fruit that I am used to with it. Instead it was a bit plain, compact and short. I have to believe that it was merely our bottle because the last time I had it about a year ago it was terrific. Not sure if this one was shut down or just off but it ultimately was disappointing given all the high expectations.
Based on my overall experience I think it still has some nice years ahead though I am not sure it will get any better with long term aging.
After this weekend, I think my new favorite Grenache is Into the Dark which is performing better than ever.
I’ve had the Gewurtz at a showing of the all the art for the labels a few years ago and Manfred and Elaine were there and brought a couple of bottles of the Gewurtz (I brought some Krug, can’t have a party without Champagne). I remember that the Gewurtz was quite good and I talked with Manfred about it. Had a bit of sweetness IIRC.
Great notes and awesome photos. Looks like wallpaper to me.
Justin - another amazing SQN event.
Not surprised (but jealous) that Winnick was there. I know he’s busy these days, but do you think any of you can encourage him to post his impressions?
Also, I just got back from a Chave dinner where we had the 1998…we were dead on about the 1998 Hospice…would have made for a very interesting comparison.
More notes and pics to come when I finally get the chance…just to show how busy Jeff really is, he was an hour late on Friday…though of course we waited…
Unfortunately, given the quantity of bottlings to cover the vertical as we did, there was no way to add the nine pinots as well…though, CF is indeed drinking really, really well right now!
Kidding aside, was Paul E. Himes drunk AND high when he wrote these “notes”??? Not only do they not say ANYTHING intelligible about the actual wine (except maybe part of the wine’s name in the “note”) but they are borderline offensive and misogynistic. WTF man???