MChang…you are indeed a gentle and thanks for continue the discussion.
again taste it : with duck, with mashed potatoes and also without any food.
And then vote on them. In any event…different strokes for different folks.
Some like to taste wines in its perfect form and other likes to taste wine with a small effect : for example, the 1999 La Tache.
Has it reach its maturity yet ?
If the wine group all decide it needs to wait for 2 years more.
OK, taste it again 2 years late.
After 2 year, all taste it again. All 3 said yes; and other 3 said : not yet, 1 of them said, needs 2 more years, …and so on.
All can start eating the Duck…but continue to discuss about it…and they all must give the reasons for their conclusion : why it is now mature and other must provide reason…why 2 years and not 4.