TN: Chave in the afternoon 04 CdC, 85,90,97 red and 90 white

Four close friends got together last weekend to share some simple food and better wines. We decided we are going to start doing some focused Saturday afternoon tastings. This was our first foray. We decided on Chave Hermitage.

Starters were conversation, some great bread, and simple snacks

[*]2004 Taittinger Champagne Comtes de Champagne Blanc de Blancs Brut - France, Champagne (5/22/2021)
A bright fresh and lifted nose with orchard fruit, toast, nutty and honeyed notes, with a touch of oxidation that adds to the whole. It’s texturally fine and beautifully detailed with terrific depth. A beautifully balanced, harmonious, lifted, wine coupling intensity with a sense of grace. Beautifully balanced dosage. Drinking at early peak right now for me. Wonderful wine. (95 pts.)

On to the reds:
We tasted all of these with bread and simple snacks to start, then revisited them all with a delicious simple rice and lamb dish made by RM.

[*]1985 Domaine Jean-Louis Chave Hermitage - France, Rhône, Northern Rhône, Hermitage (5/22/2021)
Double decanted for sediment in the AM. Drunk over a few hours.

A terrific mature nose, red fruits, with seared rare meat, olive, violet, pepper, and blood orange. This is expansive and effortless on the palate. Silky, with more olive, venison, violets, and red syrah fruit, with a terrific umami and savory side. It’s sappy and broad, yet graceful and focused with a sense of harmony. A mid weighted beauty. This has a ton going on; but more impressively, none of it sticks out, it just all coalesces into a greater whole. This is no powerhouse, just effortlessly beautiful Syrah from Hermtiage hill. This is as good as it will ever get and that is pretty terrific right now. It did start to fade a little bit after a couple hours being open, whereas the '97 kept growing. Drink up. (95 pts.)[/list]
Posted from CellarTracker


[*]1997 Domaine Jean-Louis Chave Hermitage - France, Rhône, Northern Rhône, Hermitage (5/22/2021)
Double decanted then drink over three hours

Fantastic perfume. Red fruit, olive, heme, rare roasted meat, red licorice. This wine is animated. On the palate, it is expansive, with terrific inner mouth perfume, more red fruits, some blood orange, florals, meaty and savory notes. This is in its heart a younger more energetic version of the '85 (and why I chose the '85 to drink alongside it). It was like looking at a younger sibling of the '85. This is effortlessly beautiful, having most of the charactieristic I seek in wine. If one one were to choose a Syrah to call Burgundian, this and the 85 today would fit that mold. Power coupled with grace. Terrific. I have been enamored with this wine for a very long time. It is not the most profound or awe inspiring Chave, but it is the most consistently joyful one I have drunk and never seems to shut down. This was the best bottle of this I have had. Terrific. Thanks RM. 96 (96 pts.)


Now this is a different expression of Chave than the '85 and '97. An impossibly deep nose, beguiling in a more overtly powerful mode. A darker fruited, truly stunning nose. Rare roasted game, violets, olive, and dark fruits for Chave. Expansive and profound on the palate. While the '85 and '97 draw you in with subtle grace, this commands your attention. This conveys a sense of effortless power with a near perfect balance of its savory, soil, meat and fruit notes. Expansive, structured, and seamless. There are levels upon levels of complexity in this monument to Hermitage, but it seems less meaningful to dissect it. This bottle was one that made me want to be the transparent eyeball. It was better to sit back and experience its wonders. I’ve been fortunate to have this wine several times. This bottle was incredible wine and the best bottle I have had. It was for me the apotheosis of Hermitage. Drinking at peak and I suspect will be there for another decade or two at least. Thanks AG (99 pts.)


We finished with:

A golden hue. This has passed through the in between phase and is in a fantastic place. Lanolin, honey, Marcona almonds, and apricot pit on the nose. This is by far the fullest bodied wine of the day (85,97, 90 Chave rouge). Stony, impossibly deep, texturally dense and rich, yet somehow the acidity cuts it and keeps it from being cloying. Incredible power and balance. This is a cerebral wine that I feel like I need an abacus to understand. This is great vintage of Chave blanc, and is incredibly impressive, but one glass was enough. I drank some the following few days with little change in its showing. I continue to have a complicated relationship with this wine. It is truly an incredible wine that I suspect will live for another 30 plus years, and I will continue to age mine, but I struggle with it’s both physical and intellectual depth. It is almost too much. My best analogy is one of one of my other vinous loves German late harvest wines. i am consistently more impressed with a Riesling TBA than a BA. They are a wonder, but I’d rather drink a BA or GKA any day. This is incredibly impressive wine and truly a marvel. That said, a little goes a long way for me. If you love the overt power and density that perfectly grown Marsanne from a perfect terroir can become, this will knock your socks off. (95 pts.)


Overall, a pretty terrific showing of the wines. The '85 and '97 showed the lovely understated Burgundian side of red fruited Chave and the '90 is a monument to Hermtiage in powerful year. All were terrific and made better by the company. I look forward to future iterations of the Saturday tasting.

Thanks for reading.

2 Likes

What a tasting! Thank you for the notes.

Stupendous wines. Thanks for the notes.

I just opened a 1990 chave hermitage last nigh, cellared since release. I gave it one hour, double decanted, and drank it over a two hour period. It was good, but certainly not as good as the wine you described. Did you give yours more air, or maybe just bottle variation?

Had a couple glasses of that '90 Blanc pre-Covid thanks to a generous friend and absolutely loved it. I found the balance, complexity and depth amazing, but not tiring to me in any way. That’s a wine that truly deserves a 95+ score if you’re scoring at home.

Bill, I’m sorry your bottle did not show as well.

Regarding bottle prep, the wine was double decanted in the AM for sediment then drunk later in the day over a few hours.

First, a couple caveats. I adore Chave. I adore older Chave more. This was the second time four of us have gotten together in earnest since early 2020, so those are variable which can affect perception. But, to give you my best attempt to answer here are a few thoughts:

This bottle was of similar provenance to yours. (The bottle was brought by the second owner who bought it from the original owner about 10-15 years ago who bought it on release). I’ve had a ton of bottles from this cellar and they have all shown signs of great storage.

If I were to guess perhaps a combo of your thoughts plus the human factor. I think there is always some variability with a 30 year old bottle. I think my bottle last week was on the absolute upper end of the bell curve of how this wine can show, and I do not expect another such experience with the '90 (but will be trying hard a few more times to replicate it).

I’ve posted TN’s on this wine 5 times and suspect have skipped posting on a couple I drank. There has been variation in all the bottles, but all were pretty terrific. I gave them btw 96-99 points. The last two were 97 points in '19 and '14. Skipping the numbers, the verbage on the notes conveys a variation on the wines basic underlying qualities. I think that is more important than the numbers.

I think it’s hard to extrapolate based on individual bottles and TN’s over time, but this might be of interest and is likely relevant. My least good recorded showing was when we opened the bottle the same evening we drank it. I remember the bottle well, mostly as I had been talking up the '90 so much and this was a much less impressive showing out of the gate. Here’s my TN

From the same source as my previous TN, but just opened the night we drank it. This bottle is much more primary fruit driven, with an almost pinot like suppleness. Red licorice, blood orange, singed earth, with a softer and more supple texture than my last couple bottles of this. Seamless and poised,a and less brawny profile than the previous bottles that saw more air time. This was terribly enjoyable, elegant and more fruit driven than my only two prior experiences with this wine. The person who brought this wine said the previous bottle that he SOM’d showed the same as this when he first opened it. Over around 3 hours, this gained depth, darkness, and savory meaty notes. I can only guess this will shine for the next 20 years. While, I preferred how the previous bottle showed at the time of drinking, I think this was a great bottle of wine. 96 pts.


Three of us were sharing the bottle. It started out solid, but not profound, and nothing like my previous bottle (which had been SOM’d overnight). I remember the night well, who we drank it with and where we drank it. I was feeling like I was losing some tasting street cred with my fawning over the last bottle I had. It was slow to open and only showed itself as we finished the bottle after three hours. The score was based on how it finished not how it showed early on. That said, that was 9 years ago so that is a confounding factor.

Also, and this is another situation where numbers fail. I was waffling btw 98 and 99 on this bottle, but felt it was better than the best bottle of this I have ever had which I had given 98. Admittedly, I was an easier scorer 11 years ago than I am now, so maybe that wine would have been a lower number in my mind today. I think the numbers are dumb discussion has been beaten to death, resurrection, death, zombification, then death again here. Number aside, this wine will be among the best 2-3 wines I drink this year if I am lucky, and maybe the best.

This was a transcendent bottle of wine. In a room with some pretty experienced tasters, there was silence, aside from the occasional holy $%&! and head shaking/ smiling. A Zen level of harmony and effortless beauty that is rare. I think some days you catch a wine that is potentially perfect or near perfect, you get a great bottle of it, and open it at the perfect time and the perfect setting. I think that was what happened in my case.


I hope this helps, but to be honest, I suspect it could be a ton of reasons all acting together to reach the outcomes of our individual bottles.

Thanks for reading everyone.

Todd,

Thanks for your thorough and thoughtful reply. Next bottle will see more air for sure!

Bill