TN: 5 more Chateauneufs

One day I’ll drink something other than Chateauneuf!

Domaine de la Charbonniere Vieilles Vignes 1995 Chateauneuf
A recent purchase as it was priced so well at just $21 per bottle and as 1995 is about my favourite Chateauneuf vintage for drinking at the moment I bought the lot.

A very healthy ruby to the eye with no sign of bricking. It turns out that this is more of a full flavoured rustic styled, spice & tannin driven wine than a lush fruit driven one. I suspect that if there ever was a lot of fruit in its youth, it is now starting to drop out as opposed to becoming secondary. In fact this is the perfect food wine and certainly not a wine for the masses. Drink now over the next five years if you have any. 14%vol.

Chateau de la Nerthe 2000 Chateauneuf
I’ve always wanted to try a la Nerthe and I got the opportunity this weekend as uncharacteristically these days there were a couple of bottles a few days ago at TWS, and at not outrageous prices either! This was the standard bottling and priced nicely at $30 per bottle so I snapped them up.

Popped & poured, the style of these bottles (drunk the pair) is a curious one. There seems to be far less Grenache than I’m used too in Chateauneuf. It reminded me of a good, mature CdR as this lacks the structure & potential. Sure there is spice & good amounts of fruit present but there is a distinct lack of ‘ooomph’ but it certainly offers degrees of charm, warmth and mellowness! A shame as the 2000 vintage, along with 1995, are generally my ‘to drink now’ vintages. One day I shall try the Cuvee des Cadettes & hope is a little more structure & drama. Not a bad drop, just unappreciated by me! 13.5%vol


Barroche Pure 2006 Chateauneuf
What can I say about this vintage of 100% old vines Grenache other that it’s incredibly modern, has enormous concentration, is full of completely primary rounded sweet fruit, has huge tannins, some nice balancing acidity for the meaty sweetness… blah… blah… blah. In other words it’s a big sexy wine.

In fact most amazing part of the experience was the purity of its fruit (excuse the pun…). And throughout the wine remained seamless, poised and most importantly all in balance if that’s possible for such a youngster. Later it morphs showing violets, smoke, creosote, black pepper, molten liquorice and a touch of leather too underneath the multi faceted fruit. The freshness in the finish is quite incredible. Wow, I’m going to have to bust a 2005 after that but what a brilliant $45 wine. 15%vol


Clos des Papes 1995 Chateauneuf
Some here may know that my better half does not share my vinous pleasures. My ‘discovery’ was that if just give her a glass, without mention or explanation, than she generally loves what is given! The other night it was the turn of a 1995 Clos des Papes. This bottle was a beauty, still primary fruited and tannic with the usual Avril magic kick. Some secondary nuances come along and then the most perfect long memorable finish. A stunning wine with the stuffing to show whom the boss is. I adore Clos des Papes.

But what did the wife think? Well, she proclaimed this bottle to be one of the best wines she’d ever drunk! A result!


Pierre Usseglio Cuvee de mon Aieul 2000 Chateauneuf
I bought some of these from another forumite a few days ago. I’m not sure about the theories of ‘travel shock’ or how long after delivery you should wait before busting. But as this was a reasonably youthful wine in terms of vintage I thought sod the possible ramifications!

I’m glad I did bust one after just 36 hours of delivery as it was firing on all pistons and certainly a different animal different from the delicious 1999. The shot of Mediterranean scrubland blasts straight from the glass shattering into a myriad of complex fruit, spice, herb, leather and mineral suggestions. The underlying structure makes itself felt but is balanced with the pureness of fruit although this a surprisingly tannic Chateauneuf for a wine made from the 2000 vintage. A long, long finish ends this luscious experience.

Drinking beautifully right now (decant first is my recommendation) but there is another 10+ years of positive evolution to come. A beautiful bottle of Chateauneuf. 14.5%.

I love the '95 Clos des Papes. This is why we cellar wines.

Drank 2006 Barroche Pure a couple of weeks ago. Great wine.

I know “Parker” is a dirty word here, but I wonder if the Pure would have been bought to light without his reviews?

Phil,

For most, no, however, Tim Kopec of Veritas, told me about this wine, in advance of any big Parker reviews, so I have been purchasing this wine for a few years.

That being said, most people out there wait for Jesus, located in Monkton, to give his approval.

Many of his new “discoveries” of CDP this time around, have been talked about by James Molesworth of Wine Spectator previously.

I am not saying that Parker deserves no credit, as he clearly does, but the reality is that the manner in which he tastes in the Southern Rhone these days, he is not out finding new gems. The people that run his non blind huge tastings over there, are showing him the wines. The same wines that many people have already been chatty about.

Of course, Parker has to like the wines, but it is easy to like great wines.

A very diplomatic answer, Dan. I like the wines young (although big), especially at the $$$ paid. They have all been in the £25-33/$41-55 category which is well below my budget. I do, however, wonder how a 100% Grenache wine will improve with age. I guess time will tell.

Phil,

Diplomacy is my specialty.

You get great pricing on Barroche Pure, by the way.

Whenever you come to NY, we should make sure we drink some CDP together.

I like the regular La Nerthe bottling for its lighter style and earthy/funky notes. I think it is good, but not great. Never had the 2000.

The Cuvee de Cadetes is a big step up and a richer/darker style. Damn tasty

Coelho has also been gushing about Barroche, specifically the Pure, for awhile now. (and I mean “gushing” relative to himself)

Have you ever had an older Rayas? I would say 100% grenache can age quite well.

As far as the Barroche Pure, it is not a CdP I like. Reminds me more of the Central Coast of California than it does CdP.

Is sure ain’t Rayas, unless it’s Rayas on steroids! But I’m glad I have several bottles over 3 vintages… and hopefully they will improve over the next 10-20 years.