TN: 2018 Gebruder Simon Riesling Sekt & A Philosophical Question- Long post

TASTING NOTE:
Label says 13% ABV- more than most German Rieslings I’m used to. Pours nice pale gold, looks youthful. Mousse is a little rough but it settles down after an hour. Nose is incredibly aromatic, tropical fruits, ripe peaches, jasmine and honeysuckle. The nose is so tropical; it kind of smells like a pina colada! If I didn’t know better I’d guess there was some Gewurztraminer in there. Despite the sweet nose, the wine is completely dry. Flavors are in keeping with the tropical fruits and fresh flowers I smelled initially but with the inclusion of lemon/lime. Imagine 7-Up without any sweetness: there’s an element of that. In the mouth, the carbonation is initially a bit too aggressive for me, but is pleasant after an hour. Finish is medium in length, just a touch of alcohol burn at the end. Not a hint of that characteristic Riesling petrol (which I personally don’t mind at all). Dang, I love sparkling Riesling- wish it was easier to find!

PHILOSOPHICAL QUESTION:
Why is it that the best sparkling wines tend to be made with “neutral” as opposed to aromatic grapes? Chardonnay is of course famous both for being “neutral” and a major grape of Champagne. Most wouldn’t call Pinot Noir neutral, but I had a still white wine made of 100% Pinot Noir (Emeritus Hallberg Blanc from RRV), and I was surprised by how bland the wine was. Pinot Noir is certainly a great transmitter of terroir. Does that mean it has less varietal character than other grapes? Maybe…I don’t know. [I can’t speak to Meunier specifically.]

But it is interesting that Champagne, Cava, Prosecco, the various French Cremants, top-shelf New World sparklers are, for the most part, made of grapes that are not known for their strong varietal characteristics. Surely, there are exceptions here and there: Australian sparkling Shiraz (had it only once and wasn’t a fan), Moscato d’Asti, maybe…Lambrusco? There are definitely a few examples out there, but none have anywhere near the huge global fame and renown as Champagne, Cava, and Prosecco.

I’ve only had a few sparkling Rieslings, but I think they have been great! Why isn’t it common to find a sparkling Sauv Blanc? Gewürztraminer? Viogner? Albarino? Is there something inherently “better” about sparkling wine made from neutral grapes? Is it just a coincidence that Champagne uses Chardonnay and Pinot (bc its close to Burgundy, maybe) and then became the global sparkling wine standard? What do you think???

Need acidity, as well as grapes that are just ripe enough and still get through secondary fermentation.

Well, riesling is an aromatic grape and I’d put a good Sekt up against a Cava or Prosecco any day. As far as the top-shelf New World stuff, it is clear that the model is Champagne and thus Champagne grapes are used. That said, you can find good American sparkling riesling, though it is a tough sell because at the same price point you can get good German/Austrian stuff.

You’re also harvesting the grapes at 16-19 Brix which is very early. So there it becomes a question of “which grape has some flavor at such low ripeness levels?”.