TN: 2017 Goodfellow Family Cellars Pinot Noir Heritage No. 10 Whistling Ridge Vineyard

As many of you know, Jonathan and I drink almost exclusively old world wine. We have a good deal of decades-old CA cabernet, which we love, but we haven’t bought any new world wine to speak of in a very long time. That said, I’ve been wanting to try some of Marcus’s wines, as I so appreciate and enjoy his contributions here and am intrigued by the notes others post. So when Berserker Day rolled around, I bought my first case, which turned out to include this lovely 2017. Marcus allowed as how he thinks it’s one of his most old world in character.

Knowing it was probably still too young, but eager to sample, we opened this with lunch as a kick-off to Memorial Day weekend. My note is below. Overall, I really liked it and found it scrumptious. The clarity and purity are definitely a contrast to most of the burgundy I drink and I think that, ultimately, I prefer my pinot with some dirt and density. But this bottle was a real pleasure, and I am delighted to have more for the future.


  • 2017 Goodfellow Family Cellars Pinot Noir Heritage No. 10 Whistling Ridge Vineyard - USA, Oregon, Willamette Valley, Ribbon Ridge (5/27/2021)
    With lunch in Grassl Crus stems. Lovely brightness, clarity and balance, quite pure and snappy, somewhat tart red fruit, with a little spice to it. Very good acidity for our acid-loving palates, on a stealthily structured frame. Overall an elegant and appealing wine. It did have some of that slightly candied, Ludens red cherry that I associate almost always with Oregon pinot on the nose, but not overblown or intrusive in any way. We both felt it was the best made and most enjoyable OR pinot we’ve had, though we have not tried any of the other newer and well regarded examples from Marcus’s peers. I don’t think we’ll become converts, but I’ll be very happy to follow the development of the wines and compare the '17 to the '18 down the road. Thank you, Marcus!

Posted from CellarTracker

2 Likes

a really good new world choice for an old world palate. the 17 is a good choice for that as well. also, I haven’t opened any of my 17s I bought while visiting with Megan and Marcus yet so thanks for the note!

Nice note Sarah! Glad you tried one. I love the crystalline, ethereal character that marks a lot of Marcus’ wines.