TN: 2016 Nervi-Conterno Gattinara (Italy, Piedmont, Northern Piedmont, Gattinara)

  • 2016 Nervi-Conterno Gattinara - Italy, Piedmont, Northern Piedmont, Gattinara (6/30/2021)
    An hour of decanting prior to the first glass, but still rather tight. Eventually over the three hours I sampled it there was red fruit, some floral, and a bit of red licorice, but it never truly opened up. I left 1/3 of the bottle corked up in the fridge for further evaluation, but it certainly seems that much more cellar time is needed to determine if this really has anything meaningful to offer.

Posted from CellarTracker

2 Likes

Had this about 6 months ago and I agree. Its rather tight and shut down

This was drinking pretty well a year ago - enjoyed a six pack over several months - but had plenty of fine tannin and structure that suggested they would shut down like this.

I’ve been following Nervi quite regularly going back to vintages in the late '90s and I think I’ve tasted every single release under the new Nervi-Conterno label since 2014. Suffice it to say that, at least for the time being, I liked the style under the previous ownership much better. All I’ve got so far is the big name added to the label and the literally overnight two- and nearly threefold price hikes for the various bottlings. I guess time will tell.

3 Likes

I had the rose (2019?) by the glass on Saturday and it was lovely.

That’s the big “if” for me. I tried the 2015 and loved it, so I bought a few bottles of the 2016. I’ve since found out that they made no single vineyard bottlings in '15, which might explain why that seemed so much better than the '16. I’m still hopeful that the '16 just needs quite a bit of time, and I will find out, but I really don’t know. And I am not paying the prices for the single vineyard wines. There’s too much other Nebbiolo that I know is great for that kind of money.

I am reserving judgement on my $160 investment (4 bottles at $40 each), but also in no rush for more.

I believe ‘17 is a blend that includes a higher percentage of grapes from what’s typically used in single vineyard bottlings. I haven’t opened mine yet.

The price is rising pretty steadily year over year at this point. Which I guess you could take different ways. Tegan P was on WB remarking how we’ll look back some day and be amazed we got to pay so little for the early vintages of this wine.

I have 5 or 6 spanning the last few vintages — not really sure if I should buy more or not. By the time I see where they go, they’ll probably cost too much to invest in again.

My wife visited the Enoteca Regionale in Gattinara earlier in the week and saw that even the pre-Conterno library stock has been re-labeled (magnum of '12 for 200 euros with the Conterno label). The doubling of prices has driven away virtually every long-time local (yes tongues are wagging) and the operation is definitely now being geared/marketed and priced for the export market. From a pre-Covid visit, I seem to remember the most recent single vineyards going for 75 euros ex-cellar. Another visit is on tap for later this summer and looking forward to trying the latest rosé. The wines are good and it is Conterno, but not yet convinced that the wines are following the pricing. À voir.

The rose is great. Not cheap but a really good wine. I’d buy it again.

Ah, this is what happens when corporations take over…

I’ll be there as well in a couple of weeks, but Nervi/Conterno are definitely not on my list now. It’s quite simple from my perspective: there are just soooo many other really deserving winemakers across the area whose wines are as good or positively better than Nervi’s recent vintages AND selling for a fraction of what Nervi/Conterno are charging these days. A no-brainer in my world. Plus, quite aside from the new pricing policy, I’m no longer a spring chicken, so, especially given the fact that I’m less than impressed by the new style, I’m perfectly content to leave any conclusions on the eventual evolution of Conterno’s Nervi wines to others.
(All that notwithstanding, I have to admit I am somewhat wistful about the whole thing: some older vintages of Molsino are among my all-time favourite Alto Piemonte experiences, with the 2003, specifically, just one of the best ever…).

1 Like

I just had the 2019 rose and while good, I think Proprieta Sperino’s is better (same price more or less, more mineral saltiness and more flavorful fruit too).

Hands down.

Nervi used to be one of my favorite Piemontese producers (have tasted not only a good bunch from the 00’s and 10’s, but also a a dozen or so vintages from between 1950 and 1978) but after the post-Conterno price hikes I haven’t been interested at all. They used to offer tremendous quality at 12-16€ for the basic Gattinara and stuff that competed with great Barolos and Barbarescos with Molsino and Valferana at 30-35€.

However, now that their regular Gattinara retails at prices higher than many a good Barolo or Barbaresco (or more than their old single-vineyards), I prefer to leave the wines for people who want to pay extra for the label. Like Tvrtko said, there are lots of solid producers around making stuff at the same level for only a fraction of Nervi-Conterno’s prices.

1 Like

How has the style changed under Conterno?

The '16 has tightened. The '17 is wide open. The Crus weren’t bottled separately in '17 so all of the top juice went into the standard Gattinara.

1 Like

Had the 2016 Nervi-Conterno a few weeks ago at Langhe in Chicago. I have no reference point for the wine, but certainly found it restrained, although it gradually expanded on the palate with some air. Obviously needs some bottle age, but the signature was neither tannic or acidic, just recalcitrant…

I opened my second 2016 Nervi Conterno Gattinara a few nights ago. The first bottle - several years ago - was hard as nails. After the very positive recent posts on the 2017 and 2018, I thought it was time to revisit the 2016. It was “good.” Definitely more open and expressive than a few years ago, but nothing that wowwed me. It could have passed for a decent Langhe Nebbiolo. I’ll keep hoping and wait another few years for the next bottle.

2 Likes