Lol I hadn’t even got the time to read the thread but I’m glad people still think I’m missing.
Don’t know how much it has changed. For about a year it was in a flux, but it has remained quite unmoved since.
I started working at an alcohol shop in my early 20’s. Before that I was mainly a beer and whisky guy, drank also some inexpensive wine without paying much if any attention to it since I drank it so rarely. We had monthly training / tasting sessions at the alcohol shop, which suddenly allowed me to taste so much more wine than I had tasted before, opening a whole new world in front of me - and down that rabbit hole I went.
At first I just bought and drank those wines I had tasted in these training sessions and thought they tasted good, without otherwise paying much more attention to these wines. However, the longer I worked ITB, the more I learned and understood about wine, which naturally influenced what kinds of wines I liked. When I got into wine, I enjoyed big, ripe and oaky fruit bombs, because they were so impactful and so easy to “get”. However, in probably less than a year I had tasted enough of these big wines to understand how uniform they started to seem, no matter where they came from or which grape variety they were made from. My palate quite quickly shifted to prefer lighter, drier and more nuanced wines (with a strong dislike toward oak). There has been very little change in my preferences since.
At some point I noticed how analyzing the wines while I tasted them helped me to remember them better. Writing these analyzes down in the form of a tasting note helped even better. And if I worked in a wine shop, it really helped me to work better if I remembered how all the wines I had tasted actually tasted like, so naturally I started writing tasting notes. And that kinda stuck.
Since the day I started writing tasting notes, I’ve written a TN on about 99% of the wines I’ve tasted. And admittedly that’s the way I actually enjoy wine. Breaking the wine mentally into its constituents and putting the experience into words is a hobby that brings not only gustatory but also cerebral pleasure to me. I don’t drink wine just because it tastes good, but also because I want to learn more and understand more. And I approach every new wine by thinking it is going to help me understand the wine world a little bit more.
I have now been on this journey for over 25 years. For the first 10 or so I wrote notes religiously, not in huge detail, but shorthand for me to really focus on the wines and it helped me remember the wines better. At a certain point, I realized having the notebook at the table and focusing on writing meant I was detaching from the people I was drinking with and I was missing a whole part of the experience. Now I only write occasional notes when the mood strikes and only when I am home. I particularly like using the search function and adding to threads here when notes are several years apart. It can give a picture of how wines develop over time.
I have spent the last 35 years of my life enjoying wine. When I have tried to take notes or participate in formal tastings, it distracted from what I enjoy about drinking wine. To each his/her own, but I have no interest in taking notes. I tend to over analyze too many things in my life as it is. I don’t have the time or the interest in doing the same to wine.
Out of curiosity Otto… do you write the a “full” note while tasting it or do you scribble down the most important descriptors/information, and then put it together later?
Personally I might take a few notes while drinking a wine when I am drinking on my own.
But in a setting with friends I never take notes. I just hope memory won’t fail me
Except that occasionally, I will jot down a few notes on my iPhone, the notepad app, it just looks like I’m sending somebody a text or something like that. Just a few seconds to record a few thoughts. Nothing scripted, just abbreviated comments. And then I flesh it out when I post the note.
You must be a helluva fun at the parties Otto!
I never felt the slightest urge to write notes. The memory serves well, so only mental ones, first and foremost if the wine is worth revisiting.
Like @ToddFrench ’s OP, this is the idea and the challenge. How do you best enjoy wine? Try to learn your true self and embrace it.
But it sounds easy and isn’t always so easy. Admit it or not, we are all bombarded with influences telling us what is the better and worse way to do something, that you seem cool or seem weird to do things some way.
And we like to boast that we are above that, but we aren’t. It takes thought and work to try to isolate your real self amidst all of that, and it’s an ever-moving target with ever-moving pressures around it.
Like all the important things in life, it’s a process and a journey, not a destination. Just being aware of the question and making an effort is most of the battle.
As with so many hobbies, drinking wine isn’t just about what’s in the bottle, it’s about so many combinations of things. So there are many of way of enjoying it. Some of them aren’t for me, other people are fellow travelers, either on the road to the same destination or going in generally the same direction. And with those, it’s a genuine joy to open a couple of bottles or raise a few glasses.
I used to write a lot more notes, though I’ve realized over the last year that I don’t really derive that much benefit from it, and I don’t really do it for others. My notes are idiosyncratic and not intended for others, really, so I’ve stopped. I’d rather focus on the wine, and I tend to be quite good at remembering bottles I’ve drunk. I’ve also leaned into experience more than labels - I enjoy talking to winemakers find myself chasing the highest end wines less and less; the market isn’t entirely wrong, but it’s certainly not entirely right either. Wine has also become a more intimate pursuit; I’ve mostly stopped posting the wines I drink on WB and post a lot less on Instagram - one winemaker joked last month that my feed is now mostly photos of my dog (who’s very cute, to be fair). It’s about drinking and discussing it with friends - no one needs to see what I drink on a Tuesday. And, finally, as the Russian saying goes, Век живи, век учись! - live for a century, learn for a century. So much fascinating things about wine (how to farm it, harvest it, make it, age it, what barrels to use, etc. etc.), and so little time to learn!
For me, jotting down some notes is a way of paying attention, of staying present to what I am tasting and not merely gulping the good wine down. It helps me to focus, and if I enter the notes into CT, its like a trail of breadcrumbs back to where I was and who I was on the day I tried that wine.
In social gatherings I definitely don’t make notes as much, but at home alone or with my wife, I like to write some things down.
Also, if I really like something, I am happy to praise it so a good winemaker gets some credit and fellow wine lovers hear about it. (Though I’m not above racing to buy more of favorites before I post a good note… )
It took me years to summon up the courage to actually write a note. I did write things in my trusty Hugh Johnson Cellar Book, but the idea of actually showing them to anyone else was anathema to me - far too embarrassing - also, what if someone said “Jules, that’s a complete load of bollocks!” (oddly enough, nobody has ever said that to me on WB - perhaps it’s about time they did!).
I don’t think much has changed over the years - I still find my own notes reassuringly crappy and repetitive, increasingly so in fact, since my taste has been honed over time and I rarely buy and drink stuff I don’t like - so they do inevitably sound much the same (one Sociando-Mallet doesn’t taste that different to another).
As for writing a note in the company of others - not on your nelly! I have been greeted for drinks by people who don’t know me well with a notepad next to a tasting glass, but after an evening pretending I haven’t seen it, they don’t bother if they invite me again. I can’t think of anything more anti-social than scribbling furiously while others are exchanging jokes and gossip. Worse still, I went to a tasting evening where people actually compared notes - cringe. That’s the great thing about WB and the like - you can chew the cud about wine free from social pressure and conventions, but free also from one’s own inhibitions.
Also, when I do write about a wine, I prefer to think about it first, putting it into context, comparing it in my mind to other vintages of the same wine, or other wines, in order to get a complete idea of what I think before writing anything down. Obviously this has evolved as I have got older, with the extra experience. In fact today, tasting a wine is increasingly an intellectual rather than a gustatory experience (God that sounds awful!), thinking about how good it really is compared to others.
I’m a lot less tolerant of crappy wine nowadays. If a wine is made in a style that I don’t like, or that just bores me, I chuck it immediately. Before, the puritan in me would demand that I finish it. Now, life is too short to finish a Magrez.
Stage 3.5 “Credit Rating Destruction” - Upon reading said ratings, you decide that the only way to enjoy the wine is to buy the best, no matter the price. Or perhaps more generously, the only way to understand region X is to buy the best to establish baselines, no matter the price.
Stage 8.5 “Construction” - You decide you need a cellar in the basement/garage/storage space. So proud to finally have enough capacity to manage your hobby at home, and store the wine in appropriate conditions. Then find that your storage space is full as soon as it is finished and the wine is (crammed) in.