Taking wine preference out of the equation - which region is the more beautiful travel destination?

Taking wine preference out of the equation - which region is the more beautiful travel destination?

  • 1. Chianti
  • 2.Brunello di Montalcino
  • 3. Barolo/Barbaresco
  • 4. None of the above. Rather, another Italian wine region - I’ll name in my post

0 voters

What is your top choice if wine preference takes a back seat to the destination based on sure beauty. I’ve been to Montalcino but not the other 2. Piedmont is my favorite wine region but I’m not sure Id find it as capivating as the Brunello area or Chianti for beauty? I need to go to place my, non wine geek, wife will dig too. Since we’ve already been to Siena and BdM I’m inclined to go to Chianti next but my favorite Itlaian wines are from Piedmont, particularly Barbaresco. We would try to rent a farm house we can cook in too.

Chianti
Brunello di Montalcino
Barolo/Barbaresco

So you mean just physical beauty, not other travel stuff like restaurants and activities and so forth?

I’d give Piedmont a slight nod over the Montalcino area as far as sheer beauty. There are a bunch of beautiful hilltop fortress towns somewhat similar to Montalcino, a bit more in the way of spectacular overlooks and scenic dining (like in La Morra), and the backdrop of the big mountains to the north on clear days.

Plus, if you drive 90 minutes north and visit Sacra San Michele, I don’t think you’ll find anything quite like that in Tuscany.

But I love both places. I think I’ve enjoyed visiting Montalcino as much as Piedmont, though I know most WBers would put Piedmont far ahead. To answer your specific question, I’d give Piedmont a slight edge in the beauty and photography department.

Thanks Chris, you’ve answered the question perfectly. My wife enjoys wine but doesn’t want that to be the number one focus. Even if, getting to Piedmont because of wine is a priority for me. For her its still a vacation with the focus on the entire package not just the wine. We both like taking a ton of photos.

Craig, it’s a flawed poll. Italy has practically countless wine regions. You might as well just post this on the travel board, and ask where you should vacation in Italy. Liguria has a bunch of coastline. Campania contains the Amalfi coast. Lombardy has mountains. I could go on.

Sure, Brad, I get that but, I am looking for a direct comparsion of Chianti and Piedmont vs BdM where I’ve already been. Either Chianti or Piedmont are my likely next stop but I won’t be doing both on the same trip. I had always assumed the Piedmont was the least beautiful of the 3 but it looks like I’m wrong based on my poll. What I want people to do is divorce thier wine preference from the assesment though. This would be a wine stop but the area has to be really beautiful too so I don’t bore my wife with just another wine town.

CINQUE TERRE - It’s not far from Tuscany, and very well may be the most beautiful spot in Italy -

Yep, been there twice. Love it.

AGREE - simply stunning region
(BUT the wines are … ehm … not VERY interesting)

Yes there are countless wine regions, and there are some I would say are definitely more picturesque. If prestigious wine is the reason for going, then Barolo, Barbaresco and their sister villages, Montalcino, Verona Hills etc. will appeal more.

However in the context of the request, trade down a little in reputation, then there is often a very decent compromise. Options from previous visits to Italy:

Amalfi Coast has utterly stunning scenery and plenty of charm, plus the opportunity to escape civilisation on the myriad of under-used paths that crawl up and down the hills. Wineries include Gran Furor (Marisa Cuomo) at Furore, Montevetrano nr. Salerno and a few more at Paestum, plus Mastroberardino’s experimental vineyard at Pompeii.

If Amalfi coast had me dumbstruck by the view from Ravello, Lago Molveno up in the Dolomite mountains was a more immediate ‘wow’. Plenty of similar stunning scenery, plus scenery such as the picture postcard Castello di Toblino (who do a reputedly decent Vin Santo), with fine wineries such as Foradori and Ferrari (both in easy reach of Trento). Trento itself is a recent discovery for us, but really is a very charming city, described by our friends as (like Verona before all the tourists came).

Sicily has all manner of scenery - perhaps more striking / less relaxing than the places above. Etna has strong appeal for wines these days, but has appeal for itself. The Aeolian islands (isole eolie) has a historic wines scene and individual dried grape wines (e.g Hauner). From the natural fireworks of Stromboli to the wallowing mud bath at Vulcano (basic but all the more fun for that). Salina, Lipari etc. all have a different charm, and if the weather is decent getting around by boat beats buses and trains.

Aosta has some fine wines, more AFWE than RMP, and Fumin is a really fantastic grape that seems to appeal to those that enjoy Red Burgs and Nebbiolo. The scenery is also wonderfully mountainous, but we didn’t see as much as we should have. Aosta (the city, as against the region Valle d’Aosta) is also quite appealing and easy to walk around.

Puglia has very ‘rugged’ beauty, not especially to my taste, but the whitewashed towns and villages (and the trulli houses as typically seen in Alberobello) might appeal. Easy driving outside the towns (tricky in them due to the tightness - so park the 1st chance you get). The wines can be amazing (and price isn’t always an indicator - we’ve had gems at under €10), though there are some very fine and historic producers in the area, mainly centred on the Salice Salentino region. Honourable mentions go to the very pleasant and attractive seaside town of Trani and the wines (and Castle) of Castel del Monte, plus not too far to drive to the cave dwellings of Matera. Trani is also wonderfully placed ~ 20-30 mins from Bari Airport, so makes for a great last stop without the stress of missing the plane due to traffic.

Much, much more beyond this. We’ve visited Italy many times and yet still feel we’ve merely scratched the surface. It really does give an endless opportunity to do both typical (or atypical) holidays and seamlessly blend in some interesting wines/wineries.

I hope this sparks a few ideas, and if any of the above appeal, then I’m sure I can dig out a crib sheet from the holiday prep I did when we visited.

regards
Ian

p.s. Gerhard - Sciachettra is a worthy exception - though it is very expensive for such an unusual wine style.

Lake Como is pretty stunning so I guess Lombardy fits within that area.

Hard to beat Alto Adige for sheer breathtaking beauty but you have to ask “Is it really part of Italy?”…

Well Gerhard, I love Pigato, so I love the wines there as well. Hell, I even like the Cinque Terre Coop’s white wines.

In Langhe area now, but when I was in Cinque Terre (my back to the Ligurian Sea in Riomaggiore)


. And, another shoutout for well-made Pigato [cheers.gif]

Tim
Well done at getting a sense for the steepness of the place! That said, it made for a great walk up to the Sanctuary above Riomaggiore.
regards
Ian

Neither having been named that I noticed, I’m torn between Sardegna & Valpollicella, two places about which I am passionate indeed.

Jonathan

Is there a more photogenic place? Been twice and absolutely love it!

I hate to deviate from Italy, but in France, Alsace is a truly beautiful region.

Agree; stunning region. And, in fact, wonderful wines. Very Germanic population, as Roberto suggests.

FIFY :wink:

There is no prettier or more peaceful wine region.

The dry white wines and special sweet wine made there can be excellent.

Depending on how much time you are taking, at least two from Alto Adige, Piedmont, and the Riviera could be done in one trip. Just had the chance to visit Piedmont, and the contoured valleys were very lush, with the Alps off in the distance. Had some terrific meals in La Morra, Barbaresco, Albaretto della Torre, and at the Castello di Verduno. Ours was more of a tasting/food centered trip, but the scenery made for good driving, with a bit of exploring in the local towns.