I have tended to avoid winery wine clubs because it seems that you often get more chaff than wheat. The only one I belong to is Arcadian’s GCS. However, I have been looking at the Tablas Creek wine club and it has some appeal. Would appreciate anyone’s experience with this club - good, bad or otherwise.
I avoid wine clubs. You usually have to buy some wine you don’t want, like you stated above. I haven’t looked at their website, but don’t they have a mailing list? Here in OC, Tablas Creek is fairly easy to find at the local wine store and definitely available through the usual large retail websites.
Well, Alan…to quote a famous wine critic…I’m a 96 on that!!! ![]()
I’ve followed the TablasCreek wines from the very start. Over the last 5-8 yrs, TCV has really hit their stride and my group was really liking
their wines. So I signed up for their club over a yr ago…just so’s we could get the special discount. Plus they ship some wines that we get to try
that are only available to TCV club members. Plus you can buy the Esprit and Panapolie wines on a futures basis at a good discount.
The customer service is absolutely superb. And they even send you special gifts (like a local artists wine coaster) from time to time
for your patronage. They really go out of their way for their club members. I’m happy as a skunk in God’s pocket w/ the TCV club.
So…maybe I’m even a 97 on that!!!
Tom
hard to go wrong with Tablas … and being in their club gets you access to their Panoplie, which is a real jaw-dropper of a wine.
I’m generally against wine clubs as well, but I belong to 2: Tablas Creek and McGrail Vineyards.
McGrail is for the large number of interesting member events, which I’m likely to take advantage of since I live a few miles from the winery, and the club basically says I buy a case each year and I get to choose the wines.
Tablas Creek because I was buying enough Esperit that the club discounts make it worth it for me. I love the project and the vineyards are reaching maturity. As TomHill says above, they are really hitting their stride in recent years.
I’ve also belonged to Ridge ATP but quit because I found I didn’t have a strong a preference for the ATP and I’m just as happy with their regular bottlings.
I really like the club and remain a member for reasons mentioned by the others. However, beside getting the Panoplie in the spring shipment, I have to say I’m pretty non-plussed on the others. They do have a premium membership to get only flagship wine but that gets kind of crazy at like $600/yr.
I also have quit all wine clubs except Tablas Creek Collectors club, Their wines are consistently a good value, well made and correct for the varietal.
What I enjoy most is ability to try the wines and then order more if you like something, even the Library wines they send give you a 45 day window to order more. Last falls Bergeron and Vermento where great food whites that I reordered after tasting.
Plus the Vin de Paille Quintessence is a much better value with the discount.
Really!?! I did not know about this. Basically just the Esprit rouge, Esprit blanc, and the Panoplie?
Another option (maybe — not sure if it’s still an option or not) is Tablas’ VINdependent membership: you have to commit to buying at least 6 bottles each year (any 6 of your choosing), and you get 10% off all your Tablas Creek purchases, and you DO get access to the Panoplie – I’ve been a very happy member of the VINdependent wine club for a couple years now. P.S.: they don’t really enforce the 6 bottle minimum
Yup…DonnReisen & I used to go round&round over the Ridge ATP program. It doesn’t carry a whole lot of benefits that I can see. I think many
of the ATP wines (Ponzo/Buchangagni/Mazzoni/Caboose/etc) don’t measure up in quality to the flagship wines of Ridge. They’re not really bad,
but often they don’t excite much. And often only a small step above the 3Vllys. Still…I continue my membership. Mostly for access to their
Rhone wines. And there’ll be occasional ones that mature w/ age into something really great. But that’s a crapshoot.
Sorry for the thread drift.
Tom
I agree that wine clubs generally suck, but The Tablas Creek Wine Club is a winner. I also joined the Collectors club. This club does NOT give you access to more wine, but its fall shipment does include more wine and also older vintages. Customer service also rocks.
from my limited experience the wines age very well so the ability to buy older vintages would be a nice little added benefit