Southwold tasting of 2017s

One of the pieces of information I wait for every year is the results of Southwold tasting of Bordeaux wines, and the 10 years on which follows it. Due to covid these haven’t happened for a while, but I just found a brief article on Farr Vintners social media confirming normal service has been resumed.

The wines seem to be performing adequately, with St Emilion (not my personal favourite) performing best. I didn’t buy anything EP, and the commentary is that the wines were considerably over priced for the quality.

More detail should follow over the next few weeks as individual tasters publish their notes.

2 Likes

I should add that as well as the big boys who attend the tasting I often enjoy the perspective of Joss Fowler on his Vinolent website who gives a straight forward and honest perspective on the tastings.

A sucker’s EP

Joss hasn’t posted anything on his Vinolent blog for 18 months Paul, but perhaps he will write up the '17 Southwold tasting?

I hope so Mark, the last few Southwold tastings are covered there though.

2 Likes

Thanks Paul - it’s always great to see who comes out on top blind. Presumably you saw Farr’s report already:
https://www.farrvintners.com/blog/post.php?post=294#

A bit surprising that they have 2017 as the 2nd weakest vintage of the decade leading up to it, as I’ve tasted a few 2017s (at the lower end) and while not exciting they’ve been very enjoyable. Of course not worth the EP price but I’ll take a flyer when they come up on clearance.

1 Like

For those that subscribe to Jancis Robinson some detailed notes have emerged. The right bank was preferred to the left bank, and Margaux and St Estèphe seem to have particularly struggled. Plenty of reasonable performances in general, but as ever, the prices would need to be right to make it tempting.

The 2018 tasting has now taken place. As usual the first comments are on the Farr blog, link below.

https://www.farrvintners.com/blog/post.php

1 Like

Solid read, thanks!

I always love reading notes from this event. I’ve tasted half a dozen 2018s single blind now and I’d generally agree that there’s some good juice made. DDC is shockingly good, juicy yet supple and almost ethereal. Rauzan was perhaps a bit below my expectations, but still very very good. Beau-Sejour Becot Becot was the one wine that failed to impress.

Paul @bbott wrote:
The 2018 tasting has now taken place. As usual the first comments are on the Farr blog, link below.

https://www.farrvintners.com/blog/post.php

That is a great read, Paul. Thank you for posting! We are starting to find a lot of the classified growths of the 2018 at our local Costco.

1 Like

Another write up from a UK merchant below.

https://www.goedhuis.com/blogs/news/bordeaux-2018-in-bottle-the-southwold-tasting

Joss Fowler has just recently posted on Vinolent Paul after a two odd year break.
You can read it here: The Last Post - vinolent.net

Yes Mark, but it doesn’t look like he’s going to doing a lot more in the near future. A pity as I felt he wasn’t trying to sell me anything.

1 Like

For those that have followed this thread before the first report on 2019 from the Southwold group is in.

It seems to be absolutely gushing.

3 Likes

Love these annual reports, Paul. Thank you very much for sharing them. I just identified a few wines that I need to order! I have only had a few 2019 wines so far, but my little anecdotes parallel what I just read, especially on the right bank wines. I still prefer the more classically structured 2016 wines, but these 2019 wines are very appealing.

Indeed, thanks for sharing, a fun and fast read.

I am pleased to have picked up a reasonable quantity of 2019s EP, including Meyney and Langoa that are particularly recommended. I need to look at more Margaux though given the emphasis in this report. I bought 6 Ferrière which I know you loved, but nothing else, and I have read elsewhere that even properties like Marquis de Terme got it right in 2019.

I’ll probably grab the Langoa Barton as well.

Just ordered the Chateau Les Cruzelles Lalande De Pomerol based on your link, the Southwold group was pretty hot on this wine, and @William_Kelley was as well. Earlier I grabbed a sixer of the 2019 Moulin St-Georges, and really dug the bottle I tried.

1 Like

He has posted again Mark

1 Like