I am in the happy position of going to San Sebastian for the first time this week, and fortunate enough to be visiting all the “right” restaurants (Etxe, Rekondo, Txispa, et al - and yes, I have read / heard the mixed recent reviews which are certainly helpful in setting appropriate expectations!!).
I have heard for years about the deep Rioja verticals these cellars hold, which I am far more eager to explore than I am to order bottle after bottle of ‘well-priced DRC.’ Alas, however, I know little about Rioja in general, and older Rioja in particular, beyond occasionally buying 80 year-old auction bottles for pebbles and typically finding them rather beautiful.
Would anyone have beginner’s advice that goes beyond consulting a vintage chart? E.g. which producers excelled in particular decades; producers to steer away from; nuances of the local classification to look out for on lists; up-and-coming producers through whom I might experience the cutting edge?..
In broad wine terms I steer toward the traditional and the hipster, and away from excessive modernity.
Alexander, sounds like it will be a great trip. Since your questions seems more specific to Rioja as a wine region and less about San Sebastián or where to order Rioja there, you might consider posting your questions in Wine Talk. That forum gets significantly more participation than your post will likely see here.
At that level of restaurant the Somms will know what you’re trying to achieve.
Our first night in San Sebastian we went to Kokotxa and spent a while chatting with the Somm. We ended up with a phenomenal bottle of white and a bottle of Valbuena. I wouldn’t have chosen either but were Somm picks to match the food. What an experience!
PS: Totally jealous. Can’t wait to get back there.
I’m not sure about the mixed reviews (I was at some of those restaurants last weekend), but in my experience your best bet for older Rioja are at Rekondo, Elkano and Ibai. Older Rioja isn’t what I’d focus on at Etxebarri or Txispa. This is, of course, assuming you’re not focused on the more Michelin star heavy places, whose lists I don’t know very well.
I am getting some noise about “it was so much better and more exciting before”. I don’t really care, I’m just using the vibes to engineer as low a set of expectations as I can!
Specifically on Etxe and Txispa - what would you focus on? The wine list will guide the way as always, but any specific nuggets would be much appreciated.
As with almost all restaurants in Galicia/Asturias/Basque region, I focus on the plethora of local white wines, which are truly excellent and among the best pairings with the food. I have zero interest in drinking way too young burgundy or other trophy bottles when the local wines are exquisite and appropriate. If you happen upon someplace that does have a bunch of old rioja, then great. But you won’t find it at Etxebarri or Txispa. We drink mostly albarino or similar, with some champagne thrown in. My advice is drink what can only be drunk there, not what you can find on any fancy wine list in the world.
Edited to add that I travel for food, first and foremost, and I want wine that compliments the food, but is rarely the main event. Honestly, there are very few places in the world I can drink better than I can drink in my own home. Yes, there are restaurants where I could buy wine I don’t currently own, but the prices are normally very high. I get that many people have a set of wines they like to drink, and so when they travel, they seek out wine within those categories. That’s fine - drink what you like, and certainly take advantage of the occasional bargain (Spain soemtimes has great prices on allocated champagne, for instance). But when I travel to a place with a set of superb options of local offerings, well, that’s what I am there for. I think of it like not wanting to stay in chain hotels that could be anywhere. Northern Spain is a treasure trove of local white wines, and it’s part of what makes it special to me to explore those when I am there, rather than drinking too young, too expensive examples of what I drink all the time anyway.
I love Basque country, I’m very much not among the “it was so much better” before crowd. Txispa has only been open briefly, it simply doesn’t have an old list of Rioja. Etxebarri has some, but it’s not what the list is deepest in. Some places still have lots of Rioja - I’ve been in the cellars at some of these restaurants and they have plenty of these wines. However, I am personally not excited by old Rioja (that is a palate preference), so don’t look for it.
At Txispa and Etxebarri I’d focus on Burgundy/Champagne and younger and exciting Spanish producers - or talk to Gabriel and Moha and tell them what you like. They love wine and appreciate fellow wine lovers.
Also, I wouldn’t necessarily lower expectations - these restaurants are great. I had amazing meals there this year.
I very much respect Sarah’s approach, but don’t personally emulate it
I am personally less interested in wine pairings than Sarah as I believe they are fundamentally less important. A discussion Sarah and I have been having for many years