With the new offering coming this week, I decided to taste through the sampler pack I bought, which had 500ml bottles of the following 2013s: Family Farm, Bearwallow, Alpine, and Horseshoe. In short, they were all too young, but ultimately (over the course of three nights) very good. Popped and poured, and drank non-blind over three nights, recorking each night.
2013 Family Farm: not a promising start for me. The lightest color of the bunch, the cork barely had a stain on it. Very tight, with more dusty aromas a than fruit. My initial (and very neophyte) impressions were that this reminded me of many mediocre Burgundies that I have had, which isn’t my cup of tea. Day 2 (and 3) was a different story. Fresh, precise, vibrant red fruit, with a very silky mouthfeel. A Pinot lover’s Pinot. This is a wine that can impress a broad spectrum of palates. I went from crossing it off my purchasing list, to needing an eraser.
2013 Bearwallow: I own several vintages of this, but haven’t opened many. As with the FF, this was very tight and closed at the start, with (to me) a slightly dusty nose, but with a slightly darker color and more dark fruit. Day 2 was an evolution in a glass. At first, it hadn’t opened up as much as the FF, and compared to the others, I couldn’t figure out what this wine wanted to be. Three hours later…the nose completely changed. Raisiny, port-like notes, with a sweet richness I haven’t had from a Pinot. It was good, and interesting, but ultimately, when compared to the others, my least favorite. But, still very good.
2013 Alpine: this has been my favorite over the years, and I had high hopes. The darkest color (barely) of the group. But, just like the others, this was very tight upon opening and revealed little. I think my biases made me like this the most of the four on night one, but I couldn’t exactly say why. My notes say this was very close in nose and taste to the Bearwallow on day one. Day 2 saw the Alpine strut its stuff, and showed me why I like it so much. Big fruit, boldest of the bunch with a very modern style. Probably not for the AFWE crowd, but maybe. Day 3 saw much of the same. Very happy with this wine.
2013 Horseshoe: not to beat a dead horse (and, not to make a pun), but this was very closed out of the gate. My notes say on day one this seemed like a mix of the FF and the Bearwallow. Day 2 saw this wine blossom. It had darkness and richness of the Alpine, but I kept finding this more interesting. I wanted to like the Alpine more, but I couldn’t do it. This was just better (for me). The best I can say is that the Alpine was more of a one trick pony, while the Horseshoe was multi-faceted. This had just about everything I could ask for in a wine. Great nose, layered flavors, depth, nuance, velvety mouthfeel and a long finish. This was the one wine that didn’t make it past day 2.
I love the sampler pack, and will purchase each year it is offered. I also love the 500ml bottles. Now, I just need to make it out there on day to see where these great wines are born.