I thought the 2013 Hobo CS had plenty of color intensity and “oomph,” though with very nice acid to keep it bright. I’d definitely take a recent Hobo over recent Camps. The Camps are good, but the incremental quality increase for the Hobo is much more than the minimal price difference.
Haven’t had these in ages (as Bordeaux takes up nearly all of the $30 Cab section in my cellar), but Souverain used to make some quite quaffable Cali Cab inexpensively. Wine-Searcher shows the Reserve can be had for ~$30. Ditto Beringer’s Knights Valley and Mondavi Napa.
Of course, these are not boutique wines and the style is/was middle of the road or worse, but in the 90’s I used to drink these with satisfaction on a grad student budget.
2012 Hardin cab is a winner, and 2013 Textbook cab is nearly as good. I think the 2014 Daou will be terrific but it’s too young for me at the moment. I would steer clear of the 2012 Arrowood. I had one tonight and thought the oak treatment way overshadowed the fruit, with a prominent signature of American oak in the foreground. Not at all my cup of tea.
Two of the contestants in our $25 Cab-off - which I hope people don’t mind me linking to each time a thread about this comes up:
Daou doesn’t use press juice so they’re Cab is much less tannic and more drinkable young. Agreed that it could be even better in 3 or 4 years.
Had one a week or so ago and thought it definitely was NOT made for early consuming. Very tannic and oaky. Has nice fruit so it will probably be safe to rack for the long haul.
Might look at the '12 Clos du Val. Had two glasses at Bistro Jeanty in Yountville, very tasty, even for $17 a glass.
Subsequently purchased two bottles–about $25. Quite good considering the price. Tried the '13 bottle, not as impressed. Have six more bottles . . . hopefully they will improve with some time (88-89 now, maybe 92-93 pts in a few years??)
+1. In a similar taste testing from easily sourced wines locally, the Daou was #1 (unanimously), Franciscan was #2, and Rutherford Ranch was #3 (mixed votes among those two). I think everyone went out the following week and loaded up on the Daou for “daily drinkers”.