Pride, Corison, Plumpjack/Cade, Alpha Omega Visit

Recently spent a day up in Napa. My nephew turned 21 and wanted to go to Napa, so he and his father came out from the East Coast. Spent Friday in San Francisco having great cocktails at Tradition and Bourbon & Branch. I don’t have any formal notes from Saturday in Napa, just general impressions…

We started our day with the 10am tour at Pride. I have been a long time Pride customer and a big fan of their wines and their customer service. As usual they did not disappoint. Scott was the person giving the tour and a great host. We tasted the latest Merlot, Cab, Reserve Cab. All of them tasted great, but in need of a good amount of time. Later on the tour, Scott asked me, what of the wines I liked of what they produced. Of course I said the Reserve Cab and Claret. Later I caught Scott and said I had recently had the 2008 regular cab and thought it was in a really good place. He agreed and said the folks at Pride have been saying the same thing. Upon our departure, Scott was giving me a few cases I had to pick up, along with a corked bottle I had a while back. Scott, rather than giving me the latest release of the cab, was able to replace the 2005 corked bottle with another 2005. Which, I thought was awesome. But, Scott also gave us a free magnum of 2008 Cab to have with dinner. We drank the 2008 with dinner and if you have one give it a try. I think you will like it.

Pride for me is a special place with very special people. Whenever I have people in town that haven’t had much experience with going to Napa, it is one of my go to places. Everyone has the same reaction to their wines and customer service. Class act…

Next we were off to Corison. I booked a library tasting as I had never had their wines. The regular tasting is $40 and $60 for the library tasting. A little steep, but I like to try something new when I go to Napa. I have heard their wines are Bordeaux in style and I like wines like Foreman and Togni so thought we would give it a shot.

We tasted a Syrah, regular Cab 2010 and 2005 and the Kronos Cab 1998 and 2003. I don’t know… I wasn’t impressed. I felt the wines were lacking and for a library tasting, I felt we were being poured the wines that they haven’t been able to sell. The 2003 Kronos was just okay and the 1998 was very one dimensional. I expect a lot more for $60 a person.

We went to Oakville Grocery for lunch and then a quick stop at Plumpjack/Cade. Not much to say, I normally like Cade, but wasn’t impressed. Maybe a little pallet fatigue.

Afterward we went to Alpha Omega. I had made an appointment about 2 months prior to our visit, but when we showed up they had no record of our reservation. So, thought here we go… However, they brought us in and handed us a glass of wine while having us wait for a few minutes. They then directed us to a nice setting outside with a great setup of glasses and food. More of what I have come to expect from an Alpha Omega tasting. We were served by Tom who was sharing duties between us and a couple of other tables. Though he was sharing duties, we never felt like we were lacking attention. Tom started us off with the whites. I’m not much for the whites, but it was nice to compare the oaked and stainless whites. We moved onto the reds and was impressed with the Proprietary Red and more so with the regular Cab. Tom then pulled out some single vineyard Cabs and we tasted George III and To Kalon vineyards which were spectacular and then the Era which I felt was their best wine. I was happy I had pre-ordered a 3 pack way back when which I was picking up. My nephew’s father picked up a 3 pack of Era and a 3 pack of To Kalon. We finished off the evening with the Late Harvest Reserve wine, which was spectacular, but at $135 a bottle I will stick with Quarts de Chaume and Sauternes…

Again, similar to Pride, the experience we always have at Alpha Omega is phenomenal. We bring people here and it certainly one of the highlights of their Napa experience. Thanks Jean, you have a great operation.

Overall another great trip…

great notes! Sucks about Corison! AO is always a classy operation.

AO’s operation is tops in my book. Had a great time there recently.

I’ve always had a great time at AO. Though the wines are definitely good anyway, it’s funny how wines always seem to taste better and find their way into my cellar more easily when they’re poured by nice, friendly, attentive people.
I actually had an appointment at Corison a while back, and cancelled it after giving it some thought. The price seemed like a flat-out ripoff for what you get ($40 for the “basic” tasting?!?)…turns out my instincts were correct. I know they get considerable love on WB, but no way am I paying that for a few pours.

We tasted with AO today and thought it was fantastic. John was very helpful and informative. We were able to taste a few wines not on the advertised list like the reserve chard, Georges III and To Kalon. It was all fantastic and we took a few bottles of the chard back to the hotel. We will be buying some more.

+1
Jean is an amazingly generous guy and we recommend a visit to all our friends!

Thanks for notes. I’d guess most people who consider Pride a special place are not going to love Corison (and vice versa)

I didn’t really love the experience at Alpha Omega or their wines? I thought the wines were just big Napa wines and found the guy behind the counter really grating. Maybe I’m just a spoilsport.

I assumed you didn’t call ahead to set up an appointment? They treated my wife and I like royalty taking us up to the private tasting room and spending hours tasting through the lineup along with barrel samples.

Yeah, you’re right and I think that’s a major difference. It pays to call ahead. We just hung out at the counter.

sounds like a nice eventful day. Too bad Cathy’s wines did not show better.

Haven’t been to AO myself, but Pride is always a must visit. Great tour + wines = fantastic experience.

1998 & 2003 @ Corison?
Wow. Talk about showing your best. You were had.

I have not had the 1998 (or the 2003 for that matter) but had read that the 1998 was a really nice wine. Not sure where but I remember the note clearly as I read it within a week after I passed on picking up some at a silly price based on the fact it was the 98 vintage. Should have done so for no other reason than to keep the vertical going but since I stopped it at 99 did not feel the need to pick up the 98.

I have had most. My point was that if you are charging extra for the Kronos, you should probably serve from a better vintage. You want to astound, no? I like Cathy and think she does a wonderful job on her wines. It has been a style I have moved away from in recent years though.

Cheers!

Well if you trust CellarTracker then the 98 and the 03 are the better vintages of the Kronos
96 - 89.3
97 - 92.7
98 - 93.1
99 - 91
00 - 91.9
01 - 90.0
02 - 91.9
03 - 93.5
04 - 90.7
05 - 93.8
06 - 91.9
07 - 90.6
08 - 95 (only one score)

Here’s my Sept. '13 review of the '98 Corison, as to which a Napa based friend expressed skepticism (“green wine/green vintage…”). I stand by my notes and look forward to my last bottle of this, maybe this weekend.

“Not merely Old World but a virtual dead ringer for a Lynch Bages: restrained and balanced, with rich notes of black currants and a touch of spiced cedar. Arguably on the cusp of its inevitable decline, but not lacking in anything on this night.”

Interesting chart. thanks.

I too am a big fan of the direction Pride has gone in since Foleys departure. I am not well versed in Alpha Omega to comment other than I see some great things about them out there. I will need to get better acquainted in the future.

+2

Rick Patton is who we’ve met on two occasions and he is a prince.

Perhaps the best tasting experience I’ve ever had.