Packing tape

It’s shipping season, which means it’s time to take things out of bulky shippers and put them into my Domaine or Uline six-paks, write stuff on three sides of them and then cram them into my increasingly unhinged-looking storage unit. The Uline upright six paks are terrible (I seem to have gotten a batch that were cut and assembled without proper prefolding to the flaps), but the Domaine lies-flats are pretty good. My problem is packing tape. I have gotten different kinds of Scotch 3M tape from Staples, Office Depot and various UPS stores which all promise to be heavy-duty, unstoppable, long lasting, commercial grade, box locking, will never fall off, hold up to 80 lbs - and sometimes that’s true and sometimes I’ll come back a week or a year later and it will be curling off.

Does anyone have a recommendation for what tape actually sticks to boxes? I’ve had better luck - sometimes - with the type that has fibers running through it (not sure what that’s called) but I don’t know if that’s the best.

Not sure if anything is perfect, but I’ve had pretty good luck with 3" tape (shipping/carton tape). If your storage is humidity is high, you might want to look into plastic bins. Good luck!

1 Like

I switched to 3M “Box Lock” tape a year ago. Pleased with the apparent stickiness but insufficient time has passed to answer more definitively.

1 Like

I used gorilla “heavy duty” packing tape for a cross-country move of my wine last year, it worked out pretty well. However, I used the 3" wide version, which doesn’t seem to be available for sale anymore. The 2" that you can find online now is probably just fine, if a bit less ideal.

1 Like

I switched to Amazon 2.8” tape and it works well. I had to purchase a wider tape gun but worth it. No complaints

https://www.amazon.com/Amazon-Basics-Designed-Shipping-2-83-Inch/dp/B0822QWLX2?pd_rd_w=45JTz&content-id=amzn1.sym.393b97ff-a095-4874-b1c4-ba61ec323005&pf_rd_p=393b97ff-a095-4874-b1c4-ba61ec323005&pf_rd_r=EEJ1EQWWG4ASHPRBJ2DR&pd_rd_wg=0TO6f&pd_rd_r=b3ce95a3-5ca8-428c-b8f3-045f5555e0a5&pd_rd_i=B0822QWLX2&ref_=pd_bap_d_grid_rp_0_1_ec_pr_bnp_bia_t&th=1

https://www.amazon.com/PERFECTAPE-Packing-Packagin-Shipping-Moving/dp/B0F7LNPJ7N

1 Like

I’d look for filament/strapping tape. The fibreglass reinforcement is super strong and it seems to stick better too.

1 Like

Any particular brand of filament/strapping tape?

Can’t say I have a brand in mind. My experience has more so been in receiving packages that have used this tape and it’s super strong and hard to remove without a very sharp box cutter, unlike conventional tape that peels and cuts easily.

Wine Consigners comes to mind as a retailer that uses this type of tape.

1 Like

1 Like

After buying a few rolls of it I am unconvinced by filament tape. I’ll go through some of the other suggestions on this list next.

Do the Gorilla or t-Rex type stuff. It sticks so well that removing it cleanly isn’t really an option.

2 Likes

The other option I’ve found is to just go all the way around the box. Even the cheap stuff will stay put when it attaches back to itself.

3 Likes