While I understand the thinking, what are the odds that one guy throws 30 bottles into recycling on the curb, and someone associated with premium wine counterfeiting manages to obtain them?
I think what you’re thinking of is an issue at the end of dinner at a premium restaurant – in that setting, there could be someone in the back room making a deal to pass the empties off to counterfeiters, so I could see defacing the label or breaking the bottle. But someone throwing bottles into recycling at home?
I don’t know if or what the potential selling value would be but I would also worry about people counterfeiting wine too.
That being said if you do end up selling them I would be interesting in buying them. I have only tried one Sine Qua Non but have always been a fan of the winery itself possibly more than the wine. I currently have 6 different empty SQN bottles and would love to have more to decorate my future cellar.
Its a bit terrifying that selling empty bottles is even a consideration from those that know and appreciate fine wine at this point.
I figure this is also how Acker/Kapon are still in business, and so many others skate after actions that would have them at minimum discredited & tossed out in other industries.
Sigh…
Terrifying? Terrifying is ISIS. Terrifying is having no money to pay the rent, put food on the table, and take care of your children. Terrifying is watching a loved one die from a hideous disease. The list goes on, but I assure you that nowhere on the list of terrifying is the disposal of an empty bottle of wine.
You might want to think about either the language you use to describe something that you don’t agree with, or recalibrate your perspective.
I find ignorant bliss terrifying. It causes lots of avoidable problems in this world, in all areas.
On a wine board, I would hope people who care enough to take the time to discuss their enjoyment of wine, especially when they are buying wines worth hundreds of dollars a bottle, would care about the health and authenticity of wines in the marketplace for all lovers of wine. If you don’t, is your choice and you are free to do as you please. But you cannot complain when you are then the victim of fraud.
I stand by my word choice and perspective, and point out that I am not going to anyone else’s work and knocking the Slurpee out of their hand…
MD