New York City Restaurants

It will also help with the problem of massive cancellations from the people who try to sell reservations and then cancel 24 hours before which is a royal pain for restaurants.


Yes I agree it’s pro-restaurant.

Through that specific problem has been somewhat mitigated by cancelation fees. Not a perfect solution of course. No call, no show predates the reservation scalping era.

I guess this is why the governor cancelled congestion pricing - more important priorities.

1 Like

its gotta make it a BIT easier right? if there’s nowhere for people with bots to sell the reservations they procure that way, it makes it a bit easier I’d think? I mean the Tatiana and Atomix reservations are gone faster than it’s even possible to refresh the page. I can’t imagine all of those went to people who actually showed up those nights. how many people build bots for their own reservations? genuinely curious


only if by “a bit” you mean some statistical possibility but effectively the same. the demand far outstrips the supply and i’m not at all convinced this law can come close to preventing all sales. i mean, anyone can make a reservation and list it on a private telegram group for sale. there’s no practical way to police this nor should any resources be spent thereon.

creating a bot to attempt to grab a reservation is trivial - if you don’t have the technical knowledge yourself, you can find someone to do it for maybe a few hundred dollars. it might suck, but given the insignificant barrier to entry, we should assume there are many doing it (there are). the effect is just hammering a website that isn’t meant to handle this use case with immense traffic.

atomix is a special case because it’s on tock - so the economics are changed slightly.

even if we assume for this argument that 100% of the bots and scalpers immediately leave the market, that still leaves every single motivated diner that’s on the app as soon as they need to be for the seat. there aren’t that many seats for these top places so it’s kind of a lottery with very long odds getting somewhat shorter, maybe.

a quick glance at dorsia didn’t show tatiana on there.

for the very small handful that have this problem, it seems their best strategy is to just charge more for some / all tables.

Before bots were here, it was often doable - not the impossible task you outline above. Some restaurants would be difficult, the Per Se of the world. But not a situation where the Raoul or Bad Romans of the world were $300 covers.

1 Like

these are two very different issues:

  1. bots making it difficult to get to get popular tables; and (though related)

  2. platforms / outlets selling reservations for money.

the factors that lead to the above are just an increased demand for certain experiences. why? who knows - social media? an increased premium on experiences? doesn’t matter

but technology allowed the market to step in and creat various ways to capitalize on that demand. recall that when resy first launched, it was all about charging for reservations - this was in 2014!

bots are just a newer method that scales for more people than having a black card and getting your concierge to do it. the best tables were always hard to get.

this isn’t new, just the methods and perhaps the attention drawn.

I guess the genie is out of the bottle and there is no putting it back

1 Like


NYT Critic’s Pick | ★★★ | American, Seafood | $$$ | 90 East 10th Street (Third Avenue), East Village


Fantastic news for them!


A little late, but not too late especially with the vast wilderness of NYC dining. Brainstorming for an anniversary dinner spot while we’ll be in town on July 2nd.

Current leader is Chambers as a little more of a casual ish spot. Good food and a “good vibe” is the type we’re going for since we’re closing on a house a week later.

1 Like



Totally forgot about Claud. Thank you as always Robert.

Has anyone gone to Sartiano’s in the Mercer Hotel?

Need a Saturday night place deep downtown, with more vegetarian options than Chambers.

Any thoughts?

1 Like

The menu at Gem is mostly vegetables. I ate there twice last week. If you don’t mind a youngish, slightly lively crowd the menu is what you are looking for.

Maybe Crown Shy?

Thanks! Crown Shy could work.

We went to Gem once, weren’t fans, but thanks for the suggestion.

1 Like

Curious, what didn’t you like about it? Also the current format which is technically Gem Wine Bar is different than the tasting menu format of the former Gem restaurant which is temporarily closed.

Bold , unorthodox ,flavor combinations that we didn’t like in 4 of 6 dishes.

We expected to love it.

1 Like